8 ms·
>> The county told NBC4 if Lucas had filled out the permit application, the owner could have learned about the shoot before he filmed there. Lol. The data on
by sandworm101 11y ago
>> The county told NBC4 if Lucas had filled out the permit application, the owner could have learned about the shoot before he filmed there.
Lol. The data on a form filed for a porn shoot at a particular location will not find its way into the hands of someone renting on airbnb. I'd be surprised if they are even digital. With due respect to homeowners, this is what happens if you rent your property. People will be having sex in your house even without the cameras. That's what people do. Owners may be embarrassed if their friends identify their home, but something is very wrong with this porn if people are noticing the architecture.
It sounds like this did not involve a home, but unit owned for purposes of being rented out. A porn shoot does not want someone's home. They, like any other production, want a film set. That means little furniture, art, or other identifiable things. So I am not surprised to see this porn shoot occurred in a rental unit rather than someone's actual home. But they should certainly have done a better job cleaning up after themselves.
- AznHisoka 11y agoI agree. Don't want this to happen? Easy, don't rent your home out. Renting your home out comes with risks, and you do get rewarded for that risk, but there's still risks. Nobody is forcing you to rent it out.
- sp332 11y agoYou're not required to take every risk with no recourse. A renter might steal from you or leave a spy camera behind, but that's illegal. We could certainly make it illegal to shoot commercial video on someone else's property without their permission.
- fweespeech 11y agoRental agreements that disallow commercial use are a thing. Much simpler and provides civil law recourse for this sort of usage.
- huac 11y agoAirbnb prohibits commercial videos/photos without permission, according to the article.
- sp332 11y agoBut what recourse does the homeowner have in that case? And being banned from AirBNB is not really a huge deterrent. Making the behavior illegal would give you more options if it happens to you, and might really make someone think twice.
- rdancer 11y agoThe contract could have fines for breaking this rule, or the property owner could require guests to agree to a fine in an additional contract on top of the standard terms. But the company has historically never had qualms about screwing their customers over, so I wouldn't hold my breath.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The contract could have fines for breaking this rule It might have a liquidated damages clause if the use of and stipulated amount of liquidated damages was such as to be found reasonable for the type of breach it covers; otherwise, a "fine" in a contract is generally an unenforceable penalty clause.
- sandworm101 11y ago> The contract could have fines for breaking this rule Small legal point. Contracts are not allowed to impose fines. They can cite liquidated damages (what most people see as a fine) but they have to be rationally related to the damage done by the activity described. They cannot be arbitrary or elevated simply to deter unwanted behavior. Yes, this is and issue when it comes to "parking tickets" on private property. 500$ fee to accommodate a cleaning crew = 0k. 5,000$ fine for pain and suffering caused by naked people in someone's home = not enforceable.
- 11y ago
- waterlesscloud 11y agoAt least in L.A. it's already illegal to shoot in a rental property (such as a traditionally rented apartment) without the property owner's permission. Still happens multiple times every day. It's more a result of much smaller video crews than anything else these days. Technically a lot of these youtube/podcaster people are in violation of local laws.
- edvinbesic 11y ago> Technically a lot of these youtube/podcaster people are in violation of local laws. Somehow I doubt that. By that same law then a family recording themselves on Christmas eve and putting the video on YouTube for their friends and family to see are also violating the same law.
- wasjosh 11y agoThat most generally wouldn't be considered a commercial video shoot.
- ryguytilidie 11y agoBut why? Seriously, I don't see why this is an issue. If I rent out my home and a couple stays there. I imagine some sex may happen there. I wouldn't care. If I rent out my home and some people have sex on camera there, and the house is returned to me in the same state, I don't care. Why do you believe this requires a law...?
- ChrisBland 11y agoI think you are being too specific in what you are saying is an issue. If you rent out your house on AirBnB, you are not expecting commercial business to be done in your home. Would you be upset if someone rented your home on AirBnB and then ran a small sweatshop out of it? What if they used it as a temporary slaughter house for animals? The base fact is they used a private property for commercial purposes when they were not legally allowed to do so. To me the general issue is private use vs commercial use.
- sandworm101 11y agoOr if an attorney rented the home for a week to meet with a client. Or even to shelter a client (think domestic violence) or shield their movements from reporters (celebs/royalty). That happens all the time, but remains commercial activity in a rented unit.
- ryanlol 11y agoWhy would any of those things be a problem as long as the house is either properly cleaned afterwards or the cleaning fees are paid.
- MichaelBurge 11y agoZoning regulations have been around for nearly a century. They caused a ruckus when they first appeared("Why can the government limit what I do with my personal property?"), but their legality is well-established by the Supreme Court. Violations of these sort(zoning, not paying property taxes, etc.) attach liens to the property, not the owner or renter. So it can be hard to dodge the consequences if you get fined. Granted, this argument doesn't apply in Houston, Texas which doesn't have zoning laws. So if the comment you're responding to truly believes his argument, he'd be forced to accept the practice in Houston.
- cleaver 11y agoI'm trying to frame this as less of a problem and more of an opportunity. Sadly, pornbnb.com is already registered. :(
- micwawa 11y agoTell Mrs. Patmore that.
- hipsterrific 11y agoThat's a straw man. While no one is forcing me to rent it out, it's common courtesy to let your landlord know of any activities you wish to pursue. After all, it's not your property you're staying in, there's a reason why you're renting it. After all, people rent out their homes on AirBnB for leisure. What porn film makers are doing is capitalizing on AirBnB rentals by circumventing not only regulations (not a fan of but sometimes it's necessary) but they're making a profit from your property. Not to mention the fact that they left this person's house a total mess which is already a dick move on the film makers part.
- oldmanjay 11y ago"Common courtesy" and "contracts" don't belong in the same conversation. It's a recipe for having people take advantage.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> What porn film makers are doing is capitalizing on AirBnB rentals by circumventing not only regulations (not a fan of but sometimes it's necessary) but they're making a profit from your property. What many people renting property out on AirBnB are doing is not only circumventing regulation (regarding, e.g., short-term occupancy rentals) and rental contract provisions (with their own landlords), but also making a profit from someone else's property. AirBnB has largely grown, and knowingly leverages (with deliberate structure to try to keep the legal risks that result on other parties in the transaction), exactly this kind of evasion of regulatory and contract restriction to make profit off of other people's property. So, while its been well-known to occur on the side of the transaction renting-out property via AirBnB, it shouldn't be too surprising that it happens on the other side of the transaction as well.
- stcredzero 11y ago> That's a straw man. That's not a straw man. It is a rather cavalier and entitled attitude, however, and I agree with you that it should be common courtesy. I have noticed a common attitude in the technology sector and amongst gamers, that if you can get away with it, then you are effectively allowed to do it, and if you're "smart," you'll heartlessly exploit all such opportunities that come your way. (Note that I am in the technology sector and would be called a "gamer" by many.) Underlying such an attitude is the unspoken belief that being "smart" makes one superior to the average person and therefore somehow entitles one to such exploitation. My opinion is that people who express such attitudes are scum who will stab you in the back if the reward is great enough.
- beloch 11y agoIt sounds like a useful tactic would be to plaster your walls with art related to Disney/Marvel characters. This would make it a legal nightmare to film in without stripping the place bare.
- rl3 11y agoEven better, mix in some QR code posters with illegitimate links to Marvel/Disney content. If even one somehow slips by the video editing crew, you're talking legal apocalypse.
- anigbrowl 11y agoNo you're not. Scienter would apply.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rl3 11y agoSure, but it would still create a legal mess and/or a large headache.
- ryanlol 11y agoNo it wouldn't cause anything at all. Nobody sane would sue for that because they might as well be taking a pile of money and setting it on fire.
- rl3 11y ago>Nobody sane would sue for that because they might as well be taking a pile of money and setting it on fire. In other words, basically what major copyright holders do every time they file lawsuits against P2P users en masse. Seems to me they're already adept at setting large piles of money on fire.
- mturmon 11y ago"Lol. The data on a form filed for a porn shoot at a particular location will not find its way into the hands of someone renting on airbnb." Hmm, if I understand you correctly, you are mistaken. If the permit is filed, the homeowner and the nearby homeowners will get paper notices taped to their doors a couple of days before the shoot (like this: http://www.wehodaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/filming-notice-beverly-wellsfargo.jpg http://www.wehodaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/filming-...). The property owner would see the notice, and neighbors push back against nearby filming here all the time, even if the property owner does not see the notice. And also: commercial users of your property for shoots treat it much differently than casual travel users will. There will be a big crew, they will have bulky/heavy equipment, they will be focused on getting a job done and they won't care about dinging up your walls, etc., in the process. A week later, you will discover something broken. Many people who let their home be used for shoots are in the industry (so they have built-in sympathy for the workers), or they are insensitive to damage because they are being paid a hefty fee, or they pay a specialist to manage their property during the shoot. They can do this because they will be paid several thousand dollars per day for the use of their home. The AirBnB rental fee would not approach this.
- kbenson 11y ago> commercial users of your property for shoots treat it much differently than casual travel users will. There will be a big crew, they will have bulky/heavy equipment, they will be focused on getting a job done and they won't care about dinging up your walls, etc., in the process. A week later, you will discover something broken. I imagine it's likely to be used as a location for some "reality" porn series (which are about as real as the average reality TV show). I can't imagine that requiring a lot of equipment or personnel.
- sandworm101 11y agoWhat many don't realize is that a "porn shoot" doesn't film just the handful of scenes for one dvd or website. A well-run production company will bring in multiple teams to film perhaps dozens of sequences in a day. One truth about porn is that, like sitcoms, they do not require large sets. So it isn't difficult to squeeze multiple teams into a house. But the upside for neighbors is that those smaller sets don't need the generators and massive lighting rigs used to illuminate wide shots. That's traditional porn. The other side are the smaller websites, often dedicated to a single actress. They want a site they can film very quietly over a couple days, usually a weekend. This is one camera, one or two lights and never more than a handful of people. They can come and go without even a van, without anyone noticing anything. Some call this "amateur", but I think that term doesn't do these productions justice.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> People will be having sex in your house even without the cameras. That's what people do. Without getting too graphic, there's a HUGE difference between people having sex for fun and a professional porn shoot. The latter is messy, smelly, and causes a surprising amount of lasting damage. There's a reason that so many porn studios film in hotels (and likewise, a reason that so many hotels refuse to rent rooms to people that they suspect will be filming there). I won't go into details on HN because it's not really the venue, but let's just say this: if you knew what being "on site" at a porn shoot really looked, sounded, and smelled like, you'd never want to watch porn again[0]. (And we're not talking about an amateur porn shoot where people just film their "normal" sex on a webcam, either - Michael Lucas literally holds the world record for the most expensive gay porn film ever made[1]). [0] Source: good friend of mine was in the industry for a while (behind the camera, not in front). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Lucas'_La_Dolce_Vita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Lucas'_La_Dolce_Vita
- sandworm101 11y agoNon-porn people are very capable of making a real mess. Talk to any hotel cleaner. People get drunk, they bleed, they get sick and even die, the later being very rare in porn.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Non-porn people are very capable of making a real mess. Talk to any hotel cleaner. I'm well aware that sex can be messy, and I still maintain that professional pornographic shoots are far worse. It sounds reasonable to compare the two, unless you've ever been on the set of a professional pornographic shoot.
- sandworm101 11y agoI didn't mean sex, just that people can make a huge mess no matter what they are doing.
- true_religion 11y ago
- randycupertino 11y ago> People will be having sex in your house even without the cameras. That's what people do. EXACTLY. Wtf do people think humans do when they go on vacation? Party, get fucked up and have a lot of sex. I'm always amused when people are shocked their sheets got dirty from renting out their unit on airbnb.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]