5 ms·
You are right about the government being able to compel some action. Where it gets tricky with Apple is around the argument that code is speech. The government
by criddell 11y ago
You are right about the government being able to compel some action. Where it gets tricky with Apple is around the argument that code is speech. The government can compel an entity to do something, but they typically can't compel them to say something.
Even though this is incredibly unlikely, say for a moment that Apple has only hired developers that feel strongly that privacy is an inalienable right. If Tim Cook concedes to the FBI and gives the order that a hacked version of iOS is to be created, what happens if his developers refuse? Would Tim Cook be put in jail, or would the developers be jailed on contempt of court charges?
- rayiner 11y agoWhat about bank employees who feel strongly that financial privacy is an inalienable right? Do they get to avoid complying with government investigations into tax evasion or money laundering? I see your code is speech point. I'm skeptical about it, because usually code is just code. It's meant to do something, not to express an idea. But I think there is some merit to the idea that code signing combines doing something (enabling code to be loaded) and communicating an idea (that the signer trusts the code). It's an interesting argument, certainly.
- criddell 11y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2016/02/26/we-asked-a-first-amendment-lawyer-if-apples-code-is-speech-argument-holds-water-heres-what-he-said/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2016/02/26... Apple has made the claim that code-is-speech. From that article: > Wayne Giampietro, a Chicago-based lawyer and longtime member of the First Amendment Lawyer's Association, said that Apple is absolutely on solid ground with its argument.
- progressive_dad 11y agoThere are many issues here which have thus far been conducted in a legal or nebulous grey area of the law or flown under the notice of the general public for far too long: Can the government compel the creation of original tools and IP outside the typical operations of a business? If so should they be required to compensate the business? Does the business then own the IP or the government? What happens when compelling a company to create IP or perform process outside of its typical operations is a net loss regardless of compensation? Should it be required to notify stockholders? Is it legal to make investments based on this PARTICULAR kind of inside government information? What if the entire company's operation may be plausibly undermined by the operation? I think a more relevant example here would be whether the government could compel a bank or financial company to create or alter its financial reporting tools to falsify data or misreport to the subject of an investigation.
- tracker1 11y agoMy understanding is the government is generally supposed to pay for the cost of external requests to private entities, should they choose to bill for it.... Unfortunately, the cost of compliance for Apple is lost future revenue, not just the technical costs of the gimped iOS version.
- progressive_dad 11y agoThe specifics are important. If I said, "If a police officer gives you a lawful order do you have to comply?" you would immediately say, "yes". Now what if I said, "If a police officer demands that an entire neighborhood be subject to lengthy interrogation and be held for 24 hours in custody in order to solve a murder that took place there." You'd probably say that's ridiculous. That's essentially what I view to be the case here. In theory the procedure may be perfectly "lawful" but in practice is clearly overreach. We need case law around this. I believe this is as clear a case of overreach as Apple could wish for. Finally, I believe it should be legal precedent set in public for once.
- harryh 11y agoRequesting a trivial modification to a piece of software is overreach?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- progressive_dad 11y agoIt becomes non-trivial due to the marketing of their devices as secure systems. Just as with the burden of proof in defamation actions is higher in the case of a public figures, the "triviality" of the modification in this case is held to a higher standard due to the purpose of the product. * I can't reply below this threshold but I'm enjoying the back and forth. People buy iphones because they believe that there are no ways to "trivially" access their personal information. Even for Apple to do so would be a breach of that trust. See: "Uber God Mode"