22 ms·
I am in the midst of negotiating an acquisition contract right now (stock purchase agreement, seller's financing note / stock power, revised shareholders agreem
by pc86 11y ago
I am in the midst of negotiating an acquisition contract right now (stock purchase agreement, seller's financing note / stock power, revised shareholders agreement, etc) as an acquiring party. Non-tech, don't think most people here would be terribly interested in it.
Based on the low two-digit number of hours I've spent reviewing documents and on the phone with my attorney so far, there are a lot of issues with the core idea of this (but IANAL).
> Where there are disputes, a blockchain can hold an objective record of events making dispute resolution relatively trivial
Good luck. That's sort of the point of contracts in the first place. To easily be able to say you agreed to something 8 years from now when a partnership/agreement has gone totally pear-shaped. And we see how well that's worked out.
> On didactic contracts: mapping out in detail every aspect of human behaviour
Good luck ad infinitum. That's just never going to happen. And this is why the first quoted passage is equally unrealistic. There will always be a nebulous area of a contract, the question is just how big that area is, how nebulous it is, and whether you're willing to accept that v. spend the additional resources to clarify it. Which with any negotiation increases the odds the other party will walk away.
> Since traditional didactic contracts are mostly unread, they do not in most cases involve active consent, which has moral hazard.
Every single word on every page of anything that needs to be signed has been read at least a dozen times by all attorneys and non-attorneys in this transaction. I'm not saying everyone reads every didactic contract but even busy people do not just take their attorney's word for it.
- vinceguidry 11y agoHmm, you bring up some good points. But there's a spectrum of legal disputes, and a range of outcomes that actors are expecting from adjudication. Obviously an acquisition is an incredibly complicated transaction, requiring an enormous amount of effort. The stakes are incredibly high. There's plenty of low-stakes commercial endeavors that aren't so complicated, but could still use computerized dispute resolution. Take a ride share. The people involved are looking to mitigate various kinds of risk. The driver wants to make sure you won't puke in his car, that he'll get paid, etc. etc. The rider wants to make sure that the driver has insurance, that he'll show up on time, and other kinds of guarantees. So you can set a flexible system whereby should either party break the terms of the contract, the software provides a path to redress. Each of these guarantees can be modeled in the software, with systems for, say, uploading photos with timestamps if the customer actually does puke in the car. The record, plus the collected history of adjudication results, provides a way for both parties to come to a conclusion about this particular dispute. Then both parties can decide whether to accept it and move on, or escalate. If one chooses to escalate, then the record of the transaction can be pulled by an appointed arbitrator and then he can add the needed human touch to create a resolution. Again, if one party is not satisfied, then he can escalate to an actual lawsuit. Over years of refinement, escalation, arbitration, the system can be tuned to such a degree that lawsuits in that arena become practically non-existent. Profits generated by the system can be re-allocated towards new market-making activities.
- kolinko 11y agoA problem, rarely mentioned, here is that if you want this kind of contract, you have to freeze money on the escrow BTC/ETH account. Imagine that if at the beginning of the ride, you had to lock off $100 in crypto, in case the driver claimed a dispute. If you don't lock the money, the whole benefit from using cryptocurrency disappears really. You might just as well have it on the paper with outlined execution steps.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Over years of refinement, escalation, arbitration, the system can be tuned to such a degree that lawsuits in that arena become practically non-existent. Sure, but most places that want this can just impose internal dispute resolution plus binding arbitration via contract, which achieves the same end without technology. And imposing this cryptocurrency-based automated dispute resolution plus arbitration scheme requires all the same social and legal pieces, plus all parties having access to and trust in a common cryptocurrency-based automated dispute resolution system as the first step. It just adds an extra required focus of shared trust compared to the status quo.
- physes 11y agoI believe you will be able to incorporate a company, including things like naming members, releasing token representations of stock etc. on the Pax platform. So the actual legal entity will exist autonomously on the blockchain. In this situation, a legal scripting language would very easily handle all the agreements involved in your negotiations- transferring ownership of the company, stock etc. The line about didactic contracts being unread was related to the example of "terms and conditions". As you admitted yourself, even for high stakes contracts it is your attorneys who read and understand the contracts, not the people who must consent to be bound by the terms. It would be better to simplify legal matters completely by focussing on executables.
- NotSammyHagar 11y agoHow will the ethereum contract program know that the worker's terms are met? If someone contracts me to build a program, and I get paid when it's done, how do you define done, which is even hard in real life. Programmatically, I could assign them ownership of a domain, or maybe a github repository? I don't see how in a world where finished is ambiguous, this can work. If this was an advertising or marketing contract, and I paid part of it as we go, how could a computer program contract know when milestones are reached? The only feasible way I see if the buyer has to say "milestone x reached" electronically. But if that's the triggering mechanism, then what happens if the buyer never does that? It seems no better or worse than regular contracting.