3 ms·
Maybe Greece Should Go Bankrupt
- _delirium 17y agoThe article keeps talking about how civil servants are overpaid, which I don't think is true. There are too many of them, but they aren't particularly well paid; the average is around €20,000.
- dantheman 17y agoIn America many civil servants are overpaid when you look at total compensation. The amount of retirement that needs to be paid is ridiculous and most govs didn't actually set aside money to pay it.
- _delirium 17y agoThat I agree with, but it's a more general issue about the temptation to make future promises you can't pay for, and is also true in the private sector. Employers in general, public and private, make promises of future payments they can't pay for, don't set aside the money, and just kick the can down the road to the next generation of management. It's one reason so many American companies go bankrupt about 30-40 years after their peak, which coincidentally is when their pension obligations start coming due.
- dantheman 17y agoI don't know of any modern corporations that have pensions -- it seems today that all companies use 401ks, they learned the lesson about pensions
- anamax 17y ago> That I agree with, but it's a more general issue about the temptation to make future promises you can't pay for, and is also true in the private sector. There's an important difference. If IBM can't pay the pensions that it promised, IBM pensioners take the hit. If San Jose can't pay the pensions that it promised, I take the hit via taxes.
- BearOfNH 17y agoIf IBM can't pay the pensions that it promised, IBM pensioners take the hit. Have you heard of the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation?
- anamax 17y ago> Have you heard of the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation? Yes, I have. It's largely funded by companies that offer pensions - it's a huge problem that it isn't completely funded that way. That's not an argument for increasing its taxpayer funding. Also, the first thing that it does is cut pension benefits. I'm the only one who is going to pay for my retirement, so I've little sympathy for folks who think that I should pay for theirs. If you're in a giving mood, feel free to kick in some money for me. If you're not willing to do that, what's the argument that I should pay for someone else's?
- _delirium 17y agoIsn't that actually worse? Not only can IBM screw its pensioners, but the pensioners have no recourse: IBM's shareholders get to keep decades of profits gotten on the basis of promises that were later breached, and limited liability means those dividends can't be clawed back to pay the company's obligations.
- anamax 17y ago> Isn't that actually worse? For whom? Not for me. > Not only can IBM screw its pensioners, but the pensioners have no recourse They made a bet. Since they were willing to take the winnings, they should take the loss.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- yannis 17y agoFrom http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/f90bca10-1679-11df-bf44-00144feab49a.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/f90bca10-1679-11df-bf44-00144feab4... On reflection, it is appropriate that the fiscal crisis of the west has begun in Greece, the birthplace of western civilization. Soon it will cross the channel to Britain. But the key question is when that crisis will reach the last bastion of western power, on the other side of the Atlantic. The IMF recently published estimates of the fiscal adjustments developed economies would need to make to restore fiscal stability over the decade ahead. Worst were Japan and the UK (a fiscal tightening of 13 per cent of GDP). Then came Ireland, Spain and Greece (9 per cent). And in sixth place? Step forward America, which would need to tighten fiscal policy by 8.8 per cent of GDP to satisfy the IMF.
- emilind 17y agoCato will never go bankrupt 'cos the wingnut welfare don't stop.
- rglovejoy 17y agoFlagged. This is not Reddit.
- emilind 17y agoI'm sorry, people are free to post right-wing propaganda, but not free to comment on it?
- falsestprophet 17y agoIdeally they would comment coherently in the Queen's English.
- rglovejoy 17y agoYour comment lacked substance, that is why I flagged it. The article itself was not propaganda, right-wing or otherwise. Calling people wingnuts does not contribute to the conversation.
- _delirium 17y agoI suppose the ideal would be not to have such articles posted at all, since this isn't really the place for this sort of hyper-partisan stuff, whether from Cato or the Socialist Worker.
- iujhygfbh 17y agoWhat exactly does it mean for a country to go bankrupt? Do the creditors get the assets? If a chinese construction company is owed money for a government project do they get part of the country?
- _delirium 17y agoIt just means they default on the loans. The creditors only get what the country chooses to give them (if anything), which is usually negotiated with some eye towards balancing the country's interests against the harm to their future ability to get loans if they screw the creditors too much. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Default_(finance)#Sovereign_defaults http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Default_(finance)#Sovereign_def...
- iujhygfbh 17y agoBut bankrupt means you don't run the company/country anymore - they call in the receivers, and KPMG or whoever sell off the assets for scrap.
- _delirium 17y agoYeah, from that definition of bankruptcy it's a poor choice of words, because sovereign countries can't go bankrupt in the sense that bankruptcy law means. They're colloquially bankrupt in the sense of "not able to pay their bills", but not legally in the sense of "in court-supervised receivership"--- because there is no world government, and therefore no bankruptcy court with jurisdiction.
- iujhygfbh 17y agoInteresting idea though for a small country like Tuvavlu - just sell the country to the highest bidder. If say an online gambling company wants to be sure of favorable treatment it could just buy the government wholesale instead of having to buy it one politician at a time. It's only what say Lichtenstein, the channel islands, Bermuda have de-facto done.
- emilind 17y agoThis is fun, maybe I can get my points into negative territory!
- dkimball 17y agoI'm not a libertarian, to say the least, but I think that this writer has a point. I don't know where the saying originates that "a democracy only survives until its citizens realize that they can vote themselves money" -- I believe it was a British historian writing about Athens in the 1750s -- but it's intensely relevant here. Greece, or any country, can only support a large public sector (apparently not overpaid so much as overpopulated) on the back of a large productive sector -- not necessarily a private sector (just ask the People's Liberation Army and its subsidiaries), but something or other that's generating wealth. I'd also emphasize _delerium's passing comment about a state needing to worry about its future ability to get loans. The combination of the Industrial Revolution and pogrom-proof banking have made this less likely, but as late as the 18th century there was always the possibility of a country running out of money; Philip II's bankruptcy is a particularly famous one. If that (or extreme inflation) starts happening again, it will make everyone's lives harder.