3 ms·
It's Twitter's platform; they can do whatever the fuck they want. The First Amendment does not apply. If they wish to ban hate speech and apply strict disciplin
by bitwize 11y ago
It's Twitter's platform; they can do whatever the fuck they want. The First Amendment does not apply. If they wish to ban hate speech and apply strict disciplinary action to users who post such speech, more power to them. Let the conservative hatemongers form their own microblogging echo chamber. I'm sure it will take off and be read by hundreds of millions like Conservapedia did. Oh wait...
- pjc50 11y agoI think that's what menshn was supposed to be.
- bprieto 11y agoI agree that a private company should be free to choose to not deal with some people because of their political positions. But I also think a private company should be free to choose to not deal with some people for their sexual choices. So a bakery can do whatever the fuck they want if a gay couple ask for a wedding cacke. Personally, I would never do business with a company that is racist, sexist or discriminatory in any way, but I defend the right to be racist, sexist, discriminatory or a general asshole in your private endeavours. I value freedom over feelings.
- hga 11y agoTo quote David "Iowahawk" Burge, "Twitter is a private firm & perfectly free to ban/shadowban me or anyone else. It's not like I'm asking them to bake me a gay wedding cake." (https://twitter.com/iowahawkblog/status/701077040238194688 https://twitter.com/iowahawkblog/status/701077040238194688). (Oops, just noticed I'm echoing bprieto who made this point an hour earlier.) I'd add their platform is every bit their own as that of a Mississippi lunch counter owners'. The ship you claim is protecting them sailed decades ago. Further, it isn't their's after they IPOed, it's their shareholders, who might want a word with them about driving away half their user base....
- cabalamat 11y ago> It's Twitter's platform; they can do whatever the fuck they want. What if the same company controlled Twitter, Facebook, and Google? And what if that company decided to subtly give more prominence to political views they liked and less to ones they disliked? They could probably decide an election by doing that. > If they wish to ban hate speech and apply strict disciplinary action to users who post such speech, more power to them. And if they choose to give less prominence to politicians who think big internet corporations should pay more tax, do you still think "more power to them"? Are you sure you want them to have that much power? Powrer corrupts. The more power an entity has, the more they will be corrupted by it, and abuse their power. That's why it is unwise to concentrate power in a few hands.
- maldusiecle 11y agoRight, which is exactly why the same company shouldn't control Twitter, Facebook, and Google, whether or not any of the individual companies are enacting deliberate political censorship. As it is, though, there are many social media networks, and users are free to choose the one that fits their needs. If a user finds Twitter too aggressive in weeding out misogynistic and racist hate speech, they can easily switch to Reddit, which takes a more hands-off approach.