3 ms·
> > his opinion should carry a lot of weight > That's nice, but it's only one side. What about the opinion of the developers who wrote the module and licensed
by cyphar 11y ago
> > his opinion should carry a lot of weight
> That's nice, but it's only one side. What about the opinion of the developers who wrote the module and licensed it under CDDL?
The developers' opinions don't matter. All contributors used to have to sign a CLA to give copyright to Sun. Then Sun was bought by Oracle. So you should care about what Oracle thinks about copyright infringement.
> The incompatibility between CDDL and GPL is well-known, and the authors at Sun made it that way deliberately.
No, that's bullshit. CDDL (which is just the MPL) is a file-based copyleft because that's what license fitted their requirements. It's not their fault that people have a completely fucked up interpretation of "derivative work" that includes any combination of two completely separately developed works.
- csirac2 11y ago> It's not their fault that people have a completely fucked up interpretation of "derivative work" that includes any combination of two completely separately developed works. Indeed, "derivative work" is a well-understood term of art in Copyright law. So the courts will have to decide if that's truly what they will interpret, or will they take the redistribution & usage restrictions of the GPL as a separable matter.
- gillianseed 11y agoOh please, even the author of the CDDL license states that this is so (Danese Cooper). And it's not as if that admission was ever needed, were you even around back then ? Solaris was being killed in the market by Linux, Sun decided to go open source in an effort to better compete with Linux, but there was NO way that they would give away their prized technology (ZFS, DTrace) under a license which would allow their main competitor to whom they were losing, to integrate said technology. Hence CDDL, GPLv2 incompatible.
- cyphar 11y ago> Oh please, even the author of the CDDL license states that this is so (Danese Cooper). Wikipedia mentions several other authors. Maybe Wikipedia is wrong, but I am doubtful only one person wrote the CDDL. > Solaris was being killed in the market by Linux, Sun decided to go open source in an effort to better compete with Linux, but there was NO way that they would give away their prized technology (ZFS, DTrace) under a license which would allow their main competitor to whom they were losing, to integrate said technology. That is one telling of the story. Other Sun employees have different tellings. It's not as cut and dry as you claim. CDDL is GPL incompatible in a very subtle way. The copyright of the CDDL licensed code isn't infringed, it's technically the copyright of the GPL code that's infringed. CDDL allows distribution of the binaries under a different license (provided the license doesn't restrict the users' rights, which the GPL doesn't), but the source files must always be under the same license. The GPL requires the source files for the "dervied work" be under the same license, which is where the incompatibility steps in.
- carussell 11y ago> The developers' opinions don't matter I don't see how that's supposed to make sense. The developers/their employers retain copyright to their contributions—even those who signed the contributor agreement. (And it's dead, by the way. Nobody new is signing that agreement, and there's a backlog containing years of changes where the agreement doesn't apply.) So in a world where Oracle is making no indication of changing those terms, the developers' opinions do matter. And I'm very specifically not just talking about the ZFS people here. This isn't "the ZFS license"; it's the CDDL. There's other software released under the CDDL. > No, that's bullshit. CDDL (which is just the MPL) is a file-based copyleft because that's what license fitted their requirements. It's not their fault that people have a completely fucked up interpretation of "derivative work" that includes any combination of two completely separately developed works. Again, this is completely incoherent to me. I recognize the words you're using, and I see that they're arranged in valid sentence structure, but I have no idea what point is supposed to lie in it or what it has to do with what I wrote. And as I wrote to you before, the CDDL is not "just the MPL". Sun didn't just rename it and appoint themselves as license stewards when they forked the MPL. They made significant changes. They are not the same license.