3 ms·

>The "breakthrough" AI of today is deep learning on massive amounts on data applied to two areas - speech/NLP and vision. What of IBM's Watson? It's one of the

by rl3 11y ago

>The "breakthrough" AI of today is deep learning on massive amounts on data applied to two areas - speech/NLP and vision. What of IBM's Watson? It's one of the premier AI projects in the world, its specialty is neither of those two areas, and it utilizes deep learning on massive amounts of data. >How this generalizes to a super intelligence that can take over the planet is so strange. No one's really saying it does, just that recent progress in AI has accelerated such that it seems probable that even more progress is imminent. >The correct response is to say that you don't know anything about AI. I really tire of this constant appeal to authority, it's arrogant at best. By that same logic, Nick Bostrom shouldn't have even written his latest book due to a lack of technical knowledge.

bko 11y ago
Watson has a very superficial understanding of what is being asked. It would be able to tell you the answer based on the data it was trained on but it wouldn't really understand what the question meant or what the response meant. I'm sure you'd have a very difficult time having a conversation with Watson or using it on anything other than Jeopardy style questions.
- rl3 11y ago
  I never claimed Watson had anything beyond a superficial understanding, nor did I claim it was somehow generally intelligent. My sole point was that it's a state-of-the-art AI project that utilizes deep learning, and its primary specialization is neither vision nor speech/NLP. >... or using it on anything other than Jeopardy style questions. Given how many verticals IBM is building Watson for, they would likely disagree strongly with that statement.
  - dogma1138 11y ago
    Watson premier mission is NLP. It's designed to interact with humans using natural language it's designed to break down normal speech and build a cognitive process around it to get answers.
    - rl3 11y ago
      I've always thought of Watson to be an automated data analysis platform at its core. However, after doing a bit of research, you're essentially correct. Watson is technically multi-faceted, but the majority of its focus right now is NLP. In the future, I imagine that will change as they improve upon Watson's vision and structured data support.

by rl3 11y ago

bko 11y ago

Watson has a very superficial understanding of what is being asked. It would be able to tell you the answer based on the data it was trained on but it wouldn't really understand what the question meant or what the response meant. I'm sure you'd have a very difficult time having a conversation with Watson or using it on anything other than Jeopardy style questions.

rl3 11y ago
I never claimed Watson had anything beyond a superficial understanding, nor did I claim it was somehow generally intelligent. My sole point was that it's a state-of-the-art AI project that utilizes deep learning, and its primary specialization is neither vision nor speech/NLP. >... or using it on anything other than Jeopardy style questions. Given how many verticals IBM is building Watson for, they would likely disagree strongly with that statement.
- dogma1138 11y ago
  Watson premier mission is NLP. It's designed to interact with humans using natural language it's designed to break down normal speech and build a cognitive process around it to get answers.
  - rl3 11y ago
    I've always thought of Watson to be an automated data analysis platform at its core. However, after doing a bit of research, you're essentially correct. Watson is technically multi-faceted, but the majority of its focus right now is NLP. In the future, I imagine that will change as they improve upon Watson's vision and structured data support.