3 ms·
How is that even remotely similar? One has a court issued search warrant. The other doesn't. Why should iPhones be magically protected from search warrants?
by ars 11y ago
How is that even remotely similar?
One has a court issued search warrant. The other doesn't.
Why should iPhones be magically protected from search warrants?
- jMyles 11y ago1) There is no search warrant in the case in question, but an order under the All Writs act. 2) If Apple had designed the phone properly in the first place (ie, impenetrable even with their help), then they would indeed be protected from attacks via search warrant. A sufficiently robust security solution doesn't care whether the attack happens to come from the state.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> 1) There is no search warrant in the case in question, but an order under the All Writs act. I was under the impression that there is a search warrant that the government has secured to search the phone, and an order under the All Writs Act dragooning Apple into writing custom software to support the search authorized by the warrant.
- jhayward 11y agoThere is indeed a warrant. The writ was issued to effectuate the warrant.
- jMyles 11y agoRight, sure. I meant that there is no search warrant at issue in FBI v. Apple (or whatever the case ends up being called). Nobody disputes that the FBI properly effected a search warrant against the home of the shooters. But Apple is not a party to that document, and its legitimacy is not in dispute in this case.
- malchow 11y agoThis. Apple is going to lose this, and it should, under the law. It should also be free to develop a Secure Enclave that prevents iOS updates in lock, which sounds as though it is already in development.
- dragonwriter 11y agoA search warrant does not license conscripting third parties into involuntary servitude to assist with the search.
- ars 11y agoAre you sure? (Other than your inflammatory "involuntary servitude" silliness.) A warrant actually can compel third parties to help in a search. What do you think happens when a business gets a warrant? They have to assign someone to go search for and find the records the warrant asks for. Or if you serve a bank a warrant to open a safe - the bank has to go and help open the safe.
- davismwfl 11y agoWhile true, in your examples the third party is obtaining something that is already within their possession and they are not being asked to create something new. There is a reasonableness to searching for a document, but essentially Apple is being asked to create something that does not exist. Think about the first court case where this "FBiOS" is used against a person that is on trial. Wouldn't the defense have a potential field day with this, and wouldn't Apple then be drug into every trial to testify? I could see the defense claiming that because the OS was replaced it is impossible to determine for sure what the original device contained versus what the government may have added to it. Essentially from my very limited understanding of forensic techniques, techs are not allowed to ever add software to a device and can only search the device. Otherwise they are essentially "modifying" evidence. But I am not an expert in this area so I may not be fully understanding some of the intricacies.
- venomsnake 11y agoThat is so, but feds are not looking for evidence, but for operative information and leads. Anyway - there will be enough developers willing to do that if feds can obtain the source code. The trick is apple to sign it.
- 11y ago
- ta_donk_gt 11y agoNobody is stopping the FBI from doing whatever they want with the phone. They have it in their possession and have a warrant to search it. Nobody is questioning that. What is being questioned is whether a software manufacturer can be forced to build a way for the FBI to compromise the phone. This is much like the question of whether a firearms manufacturer can be forced to build a way for the FBI to compromise that type of device.
- ars 11y agoNo those questions are not at all similar, one is about a device the FBI has, the other is about everyone's device. The actual question is can the FBI force Apple to open the phone for them. That's it. Can the FBI force a bank to open a safe for them? It's not any different. Just because there is technology involved does not change the fundamental nature of the question. If you want a gun analogy can the FBI force a manufacturer to tell them the proper disassembly instructions for the gun. (For example if it needs some special tool, can the FBI force them to sell them that tool.)
- ta_donk_gt 11y agoSomewhat fair points, with a couple of key pieces of data left out: > one is about a device the FBI has, the other is about everyone's device Except that one Apple claim is making, whether realistic or not, is that once the "device the FBI has" is unlocked, it potentially exposes "everyone's device" to the same exploit > If you want a gun analogy can the FBI force a manufacturer to tell them the proper disassembly instructions for the gun Except that in the case of the gun, this is information the manufacturer already has. In Apple's case, they are claiming they do not currently have this information, and would need to do work to create the information being requested.
- ars 11y ago> Except that one Apple claim is making, whether true or not, is that once the "device the FBI has" is unlocked, it potentially exposes "everyone's device" to the same exploit The court will not care about that. The FBI is expected to open devices only with a warrant and that's it. Just because they have a tool doesn't authorize them to use it. Just because the FBI bought lockpicks, doesn't mean they can go around opening locks. > this is information the manufacturer already has. In Apple's case, they are claiming they do not currently have this information, and would need to do work to create the information being requested. Also irrelevant. At best Apple can request to get paid (and that would probably be approved). It's completely ordinary for companies to be ordered to go collect and collate information relevant to a warrant. They can charge a reasonable fee to do so, but they can't refuse to unless it would severely impact them (and the definition of severely is up to the judge). In Apple's case the Judge is unlikely to believe them that doing this would be a big problem for them - they are a huge company.