3 ms·
> because it would be hard (if even possible) to get every ZoL contributor to relicense I think this is the fundamental point that 'ajross disagrees with. Fir
by geofft 11y ago
> because it would be hard (if even possible) to get every ZoL contributor to relicense
I think this is the fundamental point that 'ajross disagrees with.
First, they could dump the code and rewrite it. That solves the actual problem (getting a ZFS under GPL) without actually relicensing. If the code from non-Oracle owners is small, that's reasonable.
Second, they could ignore their copyrights. I believe this is legal in many jurisdictions where you have many of the copyright holders on board; in particular, for many small patches, they are too small to be copyrightable. (The FSF, for instance, doesn't require copyright assignment if your patch is under 15 lines or otherwise not "legally significant", like a mechanical find/replace.) That's why Conservancy can't file lawsuits with anyone in the entire `git log` of Linux who's contributed one or two patches once, but needs someone who wrote something at least somewhat substantial.
See also this VLC blog post and its discussion of French law:
http://www.jbkempf.com/blog/post/2012/How-to-properly-relicense-a-large-open-source-project-part-3 http://www.jbkempf.com/blog/post/2012/How-to-properly-relice...
Third, per that VLC blog post, it is empirically possible to get every contributor to a large project to relicense. And VLC's ownership is almost certainly more varied than ZFS's.