3 ms·
GPL is "clearly free software" too, and FSF/OSI approved too. The problem is that the GPL and the CDDL both have no-further-restrictions clauses, as mentioned i
by geofft 11y ago
GPL is "clearly free software" too, and FSF/OSI approved too. The problem is that the GPL and the CDDL both have no-further-restrictions clauses, as mentioned in the article:
> 6. …You may not impose any further restrictions on the recipients' exercise of the rights granted herein.
> 3.4 … You may not offer or impose any terms on any Covered Software in Source Code form that alters or restricts the applicable version of this License
The situation would be exactly the same if, say, Linux were under the CDDL and ZFS were under the 4-clause BSD license, or the OpenSSL license, or Creative Commons, or the MPL 1.0, or whatever. The GPL and the CDDL both have exactly the same "problem" here.
- mioelnir 11y agoIf both licenses only had no-further-restrictions clauses, they would be perfectly fine. The issue is the imposing of further restrictions, which only the GPL has in this case. And if no-further-restrictions clauses are evil and have to go, well, then the GPL's no-further-restriction clause has to go as well.