5 ms·
I don't see this case as a particular problem. "People wanting to learn about goats" might actually be in the minority. Most people actually googling that word
by dheera 11y ago
I don't see this case as a particular problem. "People wanting to learn about goats" might actually be in the minority. Most people actually googling that word may in fact be looking for some alternative meaning because someone used it in some other sense and they didn't understand, so they Googled. And then clicked Urban Dictionary, voting it up.
However, there's a particularly interesting case:
https://www.google.com/#q=tsla https://www.google.com/#q=tsla
I don't know about you (Google personalizes results to some degree) but the first result I see is Yahoo Finance. Google Finance is second. Why is Google promoting Yahoo over their own product?
- Consultant32452 11y agoI just went there and the first "result" is a giant stock chart widget showing the 1-day chart with the options of viewing 5-day, month, etc. This chart takes up a full 1/3 of the vertical screen size. At the bottom of the chart there's 3 quick-links to: Google Finance, Yahoo finance, and MSN Money. The next result-ish thing is Google's "In the News" section that has an article about the broken Gigafactory promises. The first real result is yahoo finance, just as it is for you. I suspect it isn't so much that Google is promoting Yahoo over its own product, since that first chart is clearly a Google product, but that it doesn't bias the real search results in their favor. It's a legitimate organic search result. Most people probably just want the stock price from the first/simplest way possible, which is provided or they want the yahoo finance page.
- vonklaus 11y ago> I don't see this case as a particular problem. "People wanting to learn about goats" might actually be in the minority. This is the problem. Search isn't a democracy. I lookup the results I need, so not giving me filtering ability makes no sense. An engine that does what google does is an amazing achievement, but no longer makes sense as a model for the exact reason you gave as a defense. edit: If disagreement could be verbalized it would be super helpful to me. I have been thinking about this issue a lot, and often I see people say the same thing as me: * single website controls almost 100% of english language results * limiting of images/video from results * incorrect/wrong results * limited respect for boolean and quotation operators * high ranking sites are not authoritative, e.g. w3schools, wordpress automated blogs. * no way to filter at all But then down vote my conclusion: > searches could be filtered and parameters set by user. Really would be useful to understand my logic error, or if I have missed something.
- Nadya 11y agoBut you are given the ability to filter your results! Countless ways actually! Qualify your searches and modify them if needed. You were looking for information about goats. You should qualify "goats" with some form of "information about" statement. "goat" + "animal" makes the wikipedia page for goats the first search result. "goat" + "facts" gives you countless trivia pages, information, videos, etc Alternatively: goat -"greatest of all time" -"goatse" will search for "goat" without including "greatest of all time" or "goatse".
- vonklaus 11y agoCorrect. However the problems (as I see them now) are 2fold: No concept of time. Best case conception of time seems to be either provided by the site, "article date" or something to this effect, or t0 = when google first learned about the page. So yes, "goat" + "animal" will return your results. Try: https://www.google.com/#q=%22nodejs%22+%2B+%222016%22++mongodb+api https://www.google.com/#q=%22nodejs%22+%2B+%222016%22++mongo... Top anser for: "nodejs" + "2016" mongo api returns top hit: 2015, 2nd hit 2014. and that I can't give it context myself: I am on Mac, but my pc is broken looking for windows info or don't include Alexa1000 links as authoritative. million short (i believe) removes the Alexa1000, but not their link authority. Also, [neverShowWordpressSite unless traffic >3million unique] some larger news sites are actually built on wordpress like bloomberg. But the point is that I would delist by technology, and filter by time and tweak my authority parameters. However, if google let you do this it would exponentially compound the difficulty as the algorithm would exist on both sides of equation.
- Nadya 11y agoYou can set a time range under "Search Tools". See here: http://i.imgur.com/n5BNkei.png http://i.imgur.com/n5BNkei.png As for filtering by backend technology - I'm not sure that would always be feasible. While it may be possible to filter default Wordpress sites, I'm not so sure about sites whom backbone architecture may not be known or publicly available. E: As for your computer issue, try searching for "problem/error name" + "solved" rather than "how to fix" + "problem/error name".
- Nadya 11y ago>I don't know about you (Google personalizes results to some degree) but the first result I see is Yahoo Finance. Google Finance is second. Why is Google promoting Yahoo over their own product? Because that's how lawsuits happen. They let the search engine run itself. If more people are using Yahoo Finance over Google Finance, the search results will reflect that. I genuinely believe they aren't dumb enough to open themselves up to monopolistic behavior lawsuits. The Microsoft lawsuits weren't that long ago and I'm sure Google is wary enough to make some attempt at avoiding a repeat. I have little reason to suspect Google purposefully toys with their search results to promote their own products. Given the quality of their products - I'm more inclined to believe that when a Google product is the first result for a name/search, it's probably because people actually use/enjoy that product. As an example, Google Maps vs other "Maps". While Google is certainly trying to join the ranks, I find other "Maps" to be entirely unusable with terrible UI and am not surprised in the slightest when Google Maps is the first result when looking for directions. It could also be you use Yahoo Finance more often and thus personalized results had it listed first. Google Finance ranks 4th on the page for me for that search result.
- dheera 11y agoInteresting. But Yahoo has their own search engine. If Yahoo listed Yahoo Finance first, and Google listed Google Finance first, is there any legal issue? Both are working search engines and nobody is forcing you to use one over the other. I don't see a "true" monopoly situation. At least not a Comcastish monopoly in which other players are explicitly blocked from entering the market. For what it's worth, Bing and Yahoo also list Yahoo Finance first, if searched for "TSLA".
- Nadya 11y ago>But Yahoo has their own search engine. No they don't. They're a front-end for Bing search (at least until 2019 and in everywhere but Japan, which IIRC is a front-end for Google), but that's being nitpicky. :) FWIW I've always had an issue with companies being punished for simply being better than alternatives. That includes Microsoft's advertising IE, even if IE at the time wasn't the best browser. People were free to use IE to download a better browser, so I never saw the issue with providing IE as a default. Linux was free, they were free to buy a computer, set it up themselves, and install Linux on it. The fact that they weren't choosing to do so should not result in Microsoft being punished. However my beliefs and precedent set by previous law (even if it isn't legal precedent?) is still enough to have Google play it cautiously. Especially since there has been threat of such lawsuits if they were caught playing with their search results to advertise themselves and "kill off" competitors.
- vmorgulis 11y agoNot here but because of the "s=TSLA" in the Yahoo's url?