3 ms·
Er...this is a strange title. The closest the author comes to saying that he almost died in a mass shooting is this: > Do you know how a properly functioning s
by danso 11y ago
Er...this is a strange title. The closest the author comes to saying that he almost died in a mass shooting is this:
> Do you know how a properly functioning society would react to an event like San Bernardino? I do — because I’ve had the misfortune of living through such an event. On the 28th of April, 1996, a gunman equipped with an AR-15 assault rifle — the same kind that the San Bernardino shooters used — opened fire in Port Arthur, in Australia. 35 people were killed and 23 were wounded. It remains one of the world’s deadliest shootings by a single person.
Uh, maybe he was actually present during the shooting? But "I’ve had the misfortune of living through such an event" is a pretty vague and passively-constructed statement. It could mean that he was in Australia during the time of the shooting and subsequent change to gun rights. Which, OK, is fine -- a constructive, convincing argument need not be rooted in emotional authority...but my particular problem is that this piece is mostly invective and ad hominem...while the author's recounting of the mass shooting is brief and antiseptic.
I mean, technically, I can say I "lived through 9/11" even though it happened while I was halfway across the country...
- kelvin0 11y agoReally, is that all you take away from the article?
- vinceguidry 11y agoIt's a political article. It exists to make a point, not to provide take-aways. You're meant to either agree with it or disagree, and share it if you agree. Whatever information that exists there is only there in service of that point, limiting it's general usefulness. I hate it when people start talking politically at me in the guise of "teaching" me something.
- BWStearns 11y agoWell it's also not the title of the article (maybe it was before?) so it's a fair criticism. I clicked expecting a description of the experience, or aftermath, or something. I was however pleasantly surprised to find something I did want to read, even if it wasn't what I had intended to read.
- danso 11y agoWhat else should I take away from it? The Port Arthur tragedy is something that is cited many times in this debate -- if I had never heard of it before, sure, I'd find it enlightening. But not in the way this essay simplifies things. I haven't read much deep background into Port Arthur, but I'm going to guess that it was a lot more complicated than just "Australia collectively got its shit together" in the way that the civil rights movement, or even just the successful Montgomery bus boycott was a lot more complicated and drawn-out than just, "Rosa Parks got arrested and people got mad." When meaningful change happens, it's because people get mad and focused collective action and political strategy work together to break the status quo. The author's weak rhetorical logic undermines this concept. It doesn't even make any sense when you get past the bare surface: gun rights and privacy -- as they manifest themselves in this incident -- are orthogonal issues. By going for this angle, the author's argument for data privacy is completely undermined in a case where the attackers use a bomb to perform mass murder. Whereas I would argue: data privacy is important whether or not a massacre is committed by guns or bombs. Of course the biggest flaw in the author's argument is that the FBI and Justice Department are currently under the oversight of President Obama -- I know Trump has gotten a lot of coverage lately, but he is not the president yet. President Obama has made no secret of his personal sentiment against personal firearm ownership and it was something that was a big issue in his 2008 election. Emotions are important. But if you truly want to effect change, you have to accept that things are complicated and thus, require more intellectual and personal commitment than the self-righteous sentiment "WHY ISN'T EVERYONE ELSE SEEING HOW CRAZY THIS IS?" That said, I'd be fine with the submission if it contained what the submitted title implies, "I almost died in a mass shooting". Not because I think that one survivor's experience should dominate all others based on that one personal experience (recently, an actual survivor of Columbine made news for advocating that guns should be allowed in school) but because I'm interested in hearing experiences that I have never personally experienced, and how they've led the person to think what they think
- madaxe_again 11y ago"Almost" is a pretty subjective term. I tell people that I was two trains behind one which was bombed on 7/7 in London, and they go "you almost died!", and I just sort of raise an eyebrow, and explain that no, I went to the pub for the day, and was at no point anywhere near dead. Anyway, it's sort of beside the point of the article, but a fair point.