2 ms·
Does anyone actually believe that key wasn't already stolen by the NSA, or even the Russian spy agency, though?
by mtgx 11y ago
Does anyone actually believe that key wasn't already stolen by the NSA, or even the Russian spy agency, though?
- Piskvorrr 11y agoIf it was, it doesn't matter whether the update goes over HTTPS or not: if Mallory The Evil Empire has Alice The Carmaker's secret key, neither Bob The Driver nor Charlie The Car have a way of telling them apart. In other words, if a malicious payload is signed with Alice's legitimate key, transit security is irrelevant: you're getting a malicious payload anyway. Proving that the private key is only in the hands of legitimate user is hard, and proving it's being used legitimately borders on the impossible (scenario: Alice signs a malicious update while Mallory holds a gun to her head; how do you find out from the signature? I don't think this signature scheme has duress codes). The only thing you can do is revoke the key - but how do you distribute the revocation to the vehicles? However, this still prevents J. Random Crook from walking by your car with a USB stick and an unsigned malicious update (or serving you an unsigned malicious update while you're downloading it via his MITMed connection).