3 ms·
How big cities that restrict new housing harm the economy
- dalke 11y agoAre there any restrictions which don't 'harm the economy'? Why can't I interpret the analysis to mean the population of the city is willing to pay an extra (made up number of) $300/month per capita in order to preserve the current system? > New housing supply benefits the entire city, even if that new supply takes the form of luxury condos. Tenant activists have regularly objected to new luxury developments as just another sign of gentrification. But even if that housing is intended for high-income tech workers, it will take some pressure off the existing units that those tech workers have occupied at the expense of middle- and lower-income residents. In effect, this means that affordable housing advocates who want to block new high-end developments are simply making the city more expensive. Let's consider this more closely. Would a restriction on luxury condos harm the economy, using the same analysis factors? I assume the answer is yes. Would a restriction on luxury condos, but increasing the number of apartments, make the city more affordable? I assume the answer is yes. If both are yes, then it means that actions to make the city more affordable can end up harming the economy. Which then means that 'simply making the city more expensive' cannot be used by itself to justify having luxury apartments. If one or both is 'no', why?
- norea-armozel 11y agoI feel like the question of whether or not St. Louis (one example city) couldn't be as productive as San Francisco is left hanging. For certain kinds of industries like manufacturing, location is everything but for software development and most non-face-to-face service industries you don't need the person to be in the same city or country to be productive. If anything, the article is built on the assumption productivity is the same across all industries in as much as the methods to achieve it. An office in St. Louis is just as good as an office in San Francisco or San Jose. Equally, a person in their own private office is just as productive as someone in their cubicle following similar practices of work. Frankly, the idea that everyone has to be in SV to make the same software of the same quality and at the same productivity level is at best naive.