2 ms·
Seems to me that this goes beyond "bad stuff happens." To me, that phrase would apply to stuff like using a weak random number generator, or forgetting to check
by mikeash 11y ago
Seems to me that this goes beyond "bad stuff happens." To me, that phrase would apply to stuff like using a weak random number generator, or forgetting to check some critical piece of authentication, or accidentally leaving some test code enabled that lets people go where they shouldn't. Basically, inattention or oversights or lack of understanding.
But here, we have a system that's deliberately designed to use, as its only public-facing authentication token, a string of characters literally printed on the car. No amount of inattention or oversight could possibly lead a person to confuse that for secret data, unless they were somehow totally unfamiliar with cars.
I have a hard time figuring out how something like this could even ship. To me, this is a lot worse than responding badly when told there is a vulnerability. After all, if you think it's OK to use something any passing stranger can read as a secret key, some random internet dude telling you it's insecure probably won't suddenly make you realize you've got it all wrong.