5 ms·
Or put it another way, pretend Apple runs a storage facility. The FBI wants access to a particular storage locker, but Apple is refusing to cut the padlock on
by slg 11y ago
Or put it another way, pretend Apple runs a storage facility. The FBI wants access to a particular storage locker, but Apple is refusing to cut the padlock on the door. Very few people would argue that Apple is justified in that situation. I'm personally not sure why digital privacy shouldn't follow the same laws as physical privacy.
By Apple giving itself the ability to unlock the phone (through a new firmware push) they now have to justify why they shouldn't use that ability. If Apple never had that ability, they could simply say "It isn't possible" and could never (legitimately) be accused of obstruction of justice. Apple put itself in this position.
- EdHominem 11y agoIt's harder than pushing a firmware. You need to write and validate a special firmware with a specific weakening of some measures, and then add a protection to lock it to that specific phone so it can't be used as a master-unlock and verify that. Because of how the FBI is pursuing this, Apple will have to take all the risk. If the update bricks the phone or fails to recover the data, Apple's reputation suffers. As for storage lockers, like safe-deposit boxes, it's only reasonable for the government to ask the provider to open the locker/box because the business has the means for this. Non-payment results in eviction and probably "every day" they have a maintenance person sawing locks off. On the other extreme, Apple doesn't need to have a way to decrypt and evict your data for their general business so it's unreasonable to expect them to be able to provide this. If the government wants this lock sawed off, it needs to do it itself. (Or pay a hardware-reverse engineering company do it for them.)
- ameister14 11y agoNot really. It's more like the FBI wants access to a particular storage locker and has the ability to open it, but wants apple to build a new kind of saw for that door so they can use it on other doors later.