3 ms·
FWIW, this article has fewer than 1,200 words, just in case you were expecting any kind of in-depth analysis, and not just a tech journalist's opinion of what a
by danso 11y ago
FWIW, this article has fewer than 1,200 words, just in case you were expecting any kind of in-depth analysis, and not just a tech journalist's opinion of what an "analysis" means (e.g. something not in listicle form). Sorry to sound negative and catty here, it's a problem among journalists and the information they put out for short-attention-span audiences...once something is in scientific research paper PDF format, it's worth writing headlines about; or, if it's longform, then it just must be an exhaustively reported piece that is meaningful.
I wanted to give the author/editor the benefit of the doubt, that the headline was merely just a sly joke about "Ha ha this article is surely the most you've ever read about Burger King selling hot dogs because you probably didn't even know BK sold hot dogs did you?" instead of just the result of their in-house analytics about what makes a headline more viral...but even on that scale, it doesn't hold up, unless you really think a huge multinational company doesn't heavily think through sales impact (and production and logistics implications) of introducing something as major as a hot dog (i.e. another meat product). You don't even have to be the type of person who subscribes to The New Yorker and reads their 5,000 word articles about the chemical flavor industry...you could've just remembered that Breaking Bad episode where the guy is taste-testing chicken nuggets and sauces in front of his scientists and gleaned that food -- even hot dogs -- is a business that necessitates a lot of analysis.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- blt 11y agoYes, this author must have never read a restaurant industry trade magazine if they think this article is in-depth.
- klenwell 11y agoThanks for the review and saving me of the trouble of checking out the article. This is why I usually come to the comments before clicking TFA, even for ones with headlines that interest me. For anyone looking for an interesting analysis of the fast food industry of the sort danso anticipated with this article, I highly recommend this New Yorker article by Malcolm Gladwell from 2001: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2001/03/05/the-trouble-with-fries http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2001/03/05/the-trouble-wit... It remains one of my touchstones in understanding the fast-food industry, marketing, and American culture. (I also recommend their 5,000 word article on the chemical flavor industry: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/11/23/the-taste-makers http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/11/23/the-taste-maker...)
- jsprogrammer 11y agoEven at 1200 words, unless you have or will read a longer article, or other analysis, on BK's hot dogs, the headline is still accurate. PDF has many limitations and has been a malware vector in the past; why would you give that file format such a privileged position? I'd much rather have an open, interactive document with computational features that allow me to perform my own analysis, or to further explore the analyses that the author has already performed. For these purposes, HTML seems like a much better format than PDF.