10 ms·
Why Are So Many Animals Homosexual?
- janlukacs 11y agoso we're calling animal friends homosexual now? wow :)
- goda90 11y agoThe article doesn't even mention them having sex. I imagine theres something different between goose pair bonding and human romantic relationships that makes the homosexual label technically accurate, but not suited for equating to human homosexuality.
- fossterer 11y agoExcatly, I feel the same @goda90
- oneweekwonder 11y agoDon't know who down voted you, but I also want to know. Where do you draw the line between friendship and homosexuality in geese? Is there physical sexual interaction between male/female geese, or are they only labeled homosexual/gay because they choose a same sex partner?
- dsmithatx 11y agoSo the article doesn't really mention sex but, I wonder. When my neighbors two male dogs do the deed daily in my front yard and never with the female dog are they just friends? If only they could talk.
- StavrosK 11y agoSeems to me they're at least friends with benefits, but I'm not a canine sociologist.
- lsaferite 11y agoI find it hilarious that the author continued to use a term that is, by definition, only applicable to humans. I'd think if they were going to put so much time into the article they'd at least have the presence of mind to use the correct terminology. Based on the wording used I'd say the author had an agenda.
- Shivetya 11y agoused to be this was stated as being a dominance issue within a group of any animals. however the nature of discussions on the subject seem to get a bit silly when trying to defend a position that really doesn't need a defense.
- Kristine1975 11y agoBecause some animals fuck anything that moves and doesn't, including dead animals[1] and other species[2]. Not sure if applying human categories such as "homosexual" to non-human animals is helpful, though. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/jun/09/sex-depravity-penguins-scott-antarctic http://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/jun/09/sex-depravity-p... [2] http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20141117-why-seals-have-sex-with-penguins http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20141117-why-seals-have-sex-w...
- AdrianRossouw 11y agothe article is more about pair bonding than just sex.
- mkrfox 11y agoPeople still have trouble wrapping their heads around the fact that same-gender attraction (at least in humans) is about more than sex.
- jccc 11y ago... and in the lifelong pair-bonded geese who were the major first example in TFA.
- omginternets 11y agoI don't think that's the claim. I think the claim is that what typically call homosexuality involves pair bonding and sex.
- mkrfox 11y agoThat's not always the case. Personally, I lean toward bisexual homoromantic. This kind of split attraction is probably more common than it seems, but we didn't have language or a concept for it until recently. I know several people who are asexual and have various romantic orientations.
- deleted 11y ago
- Tharkun 11y agoIt's unnatural, I tell you. Caused by the liberal media and their leftist propaganda! Goose pride is where it's at.
- chillingeffect 11y agoI started getting the idea while reading this: What if individual reproduction is NOT the norm? What if species survival is a combination of reproduction and survival (producing food, defense from predators, etc.). What if only a fraction of a species are required to be "breeders" and the rest perform survival duties? What if the apparent majority of sexual reproduction is only a temporary abberation and now that the species has reached a stepping stone, the "temperature" on sexual reproduction is turning down? Look at bees, for example. Only a minority of them reproduce while the rest perform survival functions.
- jccc 11y agoIn the early pages of Neal Stephenson's Cryptonomicon, Lawrence tries to understand Alan Turing (who is a character in the novel): "From an evolution standpoint, what was the point of having people around who were not inclined to have offspring? There must be some good, and fairly subtle, reason for it. The only thing he could work out was that it was groups of people--societies--rather than individual creatures, who were now trying to out-reproduce and/or kill each other, and that, in a society, there was plenty of room for someone who didn't have kids as long as he was up to something useful."
- Chris2048 11y agoHistorically, people not inclined to sex with the opposite gender, still had children.
- jimmytucson 11y agoWell, the article is about the occurrence of homosexual behavior in some populations of greylag geese. I don't know how this turned into "so many animals". According to Wikipedia, homosexuality has been observed in anywhere from 500 to 1500 species -- out of an estimated 8.7 million currently living (estimate from 2011). I'm all for using science-based observations to promote tolerance but this feels a little forced.
- privong 11y ago> Well, the article is about the occurrence of homosexual behavior in some populations of greylag geese. I don't know how this turned into "so many animals". According to Wikipedia, homosexuality has been observed in anywhere from 500 to 1500 species -- out of an estimated 8.7 million currently living (estimate from 2011). Comparing the 500–1500 number (of presumably well-observed species) with an estimated total number of species is not really a good comparison. Setting aside the accuracy of the estimate of the number of species and how many of those have actually been seen/classified, what fraction of those have been observed well enough to make a reasonable determination of the occurance of homosexual activity? Certainly the fraction of well-characerized species who exhibit homosexual behavior is much higher than the 1-in-1000 rate your numbers imply.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- marknutter 11y agoThis is a little like saying "why do so many animals fall in love"? Homosexuality, like love, is a human abstraction and doesn't really apply to the broader animal kingdom. Animals are acting more on instinct than we are, and when they pair up it's due to a survivalist instinct rather than a complicated social construct. So the answer is, there are no "gay" animals just like animals don't "fall in love". We are simply projecting our highly abstract concepts onto them.
- mfoy_ 11y agoSo you think an entire field of research is irrelevant because "they're just animals"? That's what people thought about animal suffering back in the 17th century. Descartes argued that animals didn't have consciousness, even, just base instinct.
- knughit 11y agoHow sure are you that these concepts apply to us, and aren't just us making up stories to rationalize our instincts?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jhallenworld 11y agoWell here is one direct survival advantage in human society: your gay uncle or aunt may bequeath their estate to you and otherwise contribute to your upbringing (with higher probability than if they had their own kids). This is a considerable benefit, and it is to related genes.
- dTal 11y agoThat's great for you, but not so great for your gay aunt or uncle who would have been far better off (genetically) having their own offspring, and bequeathing their estate to them instead. So it doesn't really explain anything on its own.
- fhejfivjd 11y agoBecause people pushing identity politics are grasping at straws to justify their position. After all, rape is a normal behavior in animals, and is very important for reproduction in certain animals like ducks. Perhaps we should make rape the social norm too then. /s Edit: would someone care to explain how animal polygamy and rape are different from animal homosexuality?
- Cyph0n 11y agoSo many... what a sensationalist title
- elcapitan 11y agoWhy are so many animals gay? Because they're watching too much internet pornography, so let's clean up the internet to protect our animals!
- joshuaheard 11y agoThere was a study on rats that found homosexuality arose when there was overpopulation or overcrowding. This would make sense of non-procreative coupling from an evolutionary standpoint. More recently, there was a study that found a biological basis for homosexuality where there was a genetic misfire during fetal development that caused too much of the wrong hormone to be released for that gender: too much testosterone for a woman, too much estrogen for a man, resulting in the person adopting traits of the wrong gender. I see no reason why these causative factors cannot be found in the animal world as well. When people describe homosexuality as unnatural, I don't believe they are claiming homosexuality is not found in nature. I believe they mean that the homosexual sex act is not how our sexual organs are supposed to work biologically.
- acqq 11y ago> I believe they mean that the homosexual sex act is not how our biological sexual equipment is supposed to work. And that's provably wrong, as we have enough examples in nature of "sexual equipment" working on whatever.
- lintiness 11y agosure. you can stick your dick in a loaf of bread and say it's "working". his point was "reproductive" work.
- jklinger410 11y agoSo what were sex organs evolved for other than procreation?
- acqq 11y agoAs you'd see in other comments here, in our closest relatives, they even evolved to be used to support group dynamics, even to perform kind of "greeting." We have also evolved, so our organs also evolved to do what they do. Just like dog's organs evolved to even copulate with your leg. The nature is not "exclusive" the way human religions are.
- realworldview 11y agoWhy do so few animals identify as straight?
- sreyaNotfilc 11y agoSomeone in the comment section mentioned that there may be a correlation to rise of gays and the rise of urban life. Their reasoning was something about not having to reproduce. It has gotten me to think about this. In general male and females are the same except we have organs that allows reproduction. Essentially that's it. As we passed the 7 billion people mark (let alone 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 billion) do we really feel the need to populate? Sure a lot of us are embedded with sexual desires, but as the population grows sex for recreation takes place over sex for survival. This bring me to another thought about conservatives. They disagree with sex between the same gender. In a way they have a point. Googling "conservative" grants the following definition - "holding to traditional attitudes and values and cautious about change or innovation, typically in relation to politics or religion." Back in the day there was much more of a need for sexual reproduction as the human race had been plagued with deaths, diseases, and unfortunately events. There was no need for "nonsense" like having fun. We had to survive! You'd follow an order (be it wealth, race, gender roles) and that's that. As we began to master or land and really create our own destiny having fun (e.g. sex) became something to do for fun. Its a circle... Idunno, just a thought. Its an interesting topic non-the-less.
- sreyaNotfilc 11y agoSomeone in the comment section mentioned that there may be a correlation to rise of gays and the rise of urban life. Their reasoning was something about not having to reproduce. It has gotten me to think about this. In general male and females are the same except we have organs that allows reproduction. Essentially that's it. As we passed the 7 billion people mark (let alone 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 billion) do we really feel the need to populate? Sure a lot of us are embedded with sexual desires, but as the population grows sex for recreation takes place over sex for survival. This bring me to another thought about conservatives. They disagree with sex between the same gender. In a way they have a point. Googling "conservative" grants the following definition - "holding to traditional attitudes and values and cautious about change or innovation, typically in relation to politics or religion." Back in the day there was much more of a need for sexual reproduction as the human race had been plagued with deaths, diseases, and unfortunately events. There was no need for "nonsense" like having fun. We had to survive! You'd follow an order (be it wealth, race, gender roles) and that's that. As we began to master or land and really create our own destiny having fun (e.g. sex) became something to do for fun. Its a circle... Idunno, just a thought. Its an interesting topic non-the-less.
- drethemadrapper 11y agoThis is highly incorrect. Unless animals are genetically modified, they cannot ever think of being gay! It is the act of science that makes it possible. Nature won't.
- tumbas 11y agoit's because they have not a reasonable soul and are subjected to an instict. Like free masons, communists and other materialist who by rejecting their inner freedom often fall into animalistic like state.