10 ms·
This sort of analysis is helpful and needed. Explanations like "everyone is stupid" don't get you anywhere. The article doesn't say it explicitly, choosing to
by mike_hearn 11y ago
This sort of analysis is helpful and needed. Explanations like "everyone is stupid" don't get you anywhere.
The article doesn't say it explicitly, choosing to hint at it instead, but I think a big part of the popular revolt against big, remote establishments everywhere (also see: Brexit referendum polling) is that these institutions have normally made little or no effort to self police, or demonstrate any kind of ability to self discipline or self reform. The past 15 years especially have seen a more or less constant stream of scandals where people at the top of societies power structures very clearly acted badly or even broke laws, yet nobody was ever held to account ... except those who tried to reveal the wrongdoing. The track record of the elite enforcing the same rules against themselves that they enforce against everyone else is utterly miserable.
This is not a US specific thing. It can be seen to a lesser extent in other parts of the world too. One of the biggest arguments for the UK leaving the EU is that the EU has become a vast bureaucracy that is remote, bloated, undemocratic, disconnected from the people etc. The tone-deafness was made clear when the EU demanded yet another budget rise despite the fact that the member states were all trying to cut their own deficits, often by freezing public sector wages or simply laying people off.
Now mix this in with the partitioning of American society into ever more clearly distinct political tribes and it's not surprising that people who have a message of "We are outsiders just like you who won't hesitate to really shake things up" are getting so much traction. A big part of Obama's original appeal was his entirely unrealised promise to try and reform Washington. Unfortunately he lost interest in that once elected. Not that he could really have fixed anything anyway: the mismatch between emphasis on the US President and how much power they actually have is kind of ridiculous.
- bsaunder 11y agoI think you make some good points. When reality diverges from perception (as you and the OP seem to suggest, and I agree), it feels to me there a sort of economic potential energy there that may provide an opportunity for someone to capitalize on. Perhaps we need some scrambling unicorns to pivot and see how they could help improve democracy and level the playing field between the disconnected establishment and the general populace. As an individual, I frequently sigh at my ability to impact the momentum of things. The world may not be as I'd like it, but I see little I can do about that. I get that small changes by many individuals can have a big impact in the aggregate. Perhaps what would help would be a social amplifier app that would allow users to plan/schedule and participate in small changes in mass that could send louder social signals to the establishment. Maybe folks would to listen to us more frequently than once every 4 years. I'm sure there are other opportunities and the devil is in the details. I'm not saying this is easy, but society needs some new tools. The folks here on HN are precisely the right people that should be doing something about this.
- vinceguidry 11y ago> This sort of analysis is helpful and needed. It's just more noise. It's one reporter's take on current events. There's no attention given to history, or even a reasoned take on the economics involved. It's pure narrative, a bunch of facts strung together with nothing tying them together but opinion. What we're seeing is another evolution in the media-driven political cycle. Political candidacy has changed immensely in the last few years. Social media turned out to be way more politically useful than anybody ever thought it would. So candidates that use it effectively are going to be able to manipulate the news cycle more. It doesn't give them an overwhelming advantage over the traditional power base, but they have been caught flat-footed. That Americans are currently receptive to populist platforms shouldn't be surprising. We're still in the primary phase, and primaries are conducted in rural areas where the most provincial Americans live. The messaging needs to be kept simple. Once the primaries are over, the nominees are going to move to the center for the real race. Happens in every single presidential election. We're just paying more and more attention to it these day. Nobody used to care about primaries.
- maxerickson 11y agoClay Shirky recently tweeted (yeah, that's right) an interesting analysis of this: https://storify.com/cshirky/republican-and-democratic-parties-are-now-host-bod https://storify.com/cshirky/republican-and-democratic-partie...
- vinceguidry 11y agoThanks, this is much better. The "quasi-parliamentarianism" bit was fascinating.
- cdent 11y agoI'll think you'll find that Robert B. Reich's expertise extends a bit further than "reporting".
- bsbechtel 11y agoI'd argue he's part of the 'establishment' he's purporting to analyze from the outside, however.
- noja 11y agoI'd argue that media ownership by the few should not be forgotten, it has a huge influence on our opinions of huge remote organisations. If I am being constantly told that something is bad, and never told when it is good, I will gradually shift my opinion. Attrition wins.
- VLM 11y agoHere's a helpful poll: http://www.gallup.com/poll/176042/trust-mass-media-returns-time-low.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/176042/trust-mass-media-returns-t... So for 3/5 to 2/3 of the population, observation shows that a unified message from all the multinational megacorp journalists of anti-Trump hatred results in soaring poll numbers for Trump. Every time some elitist smarmy condescending newsreader indicates their oh so holier than thou hatred of Trump, his poll numbers go up a little more. Note this applies to the "other guys" too. Decades of screaming on fox news about how Bill Clinton and now Obama are going to destroy the country, planet, universe ... chicken little buffer overflow. If I can't vote for Trump I will vote for Sanders. If the establishment neocons on fox news hate him, he might be somewhat off, but also can't be that bad of a guy, I mean look at the other people they hate who aren't the best but aren't that bad. Obama may very well go down in history as one of our worst presidents, but hes just not that bad. Note that a 3/5 majority would be quite a landslide in a general election.
- notahacker 11y agoIs that the link you intended to post? Because all it shows is that only around 40% of the public trust the media (and of those that distrust the media, a substantial proportion don't trust the media because they don't think it's liberal enough). Most people are perfectly capable of distrusting both the media and the candidate that is indisputably advocating points they disagree with. Some of them distrust the media because they think it's giving Trump an easy ride. Sure, there is a demographic that sees negative coverage of Trump (and Sanders) as proof he must be the only totally honest guy with real, serious policies. But it isn't 3/5 of the population, or anything close. I mean, you'd probably find the figure for British citizens that trust the media to be at least as low. Trouble is, trust in people that the media widely dislike is even lower, and so they still lose.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y ago>The past 15 years especially have seen a more or less constant stream of scandals where people at the top of societies power structures very clearly acted badly or even broke laws, yet nobody was ever held to account ... except those who tried to reveal the wrongdoing. I find this argument baffling when applied to the EU. Most of the scandals were in the banking and finance industries, not - say - the EU parliament. The Greek debacle, which was probably the biggest failure of the EU since its creation, was created by the EU's banking and finance industries. Perhaps it's the industry that's the problem, and not Europe itself? Not that the EU isn't remote, but it's not so remote that it has no interest in promoting standards of human rights legislation. By a remarkable coincidence, a key foundation of Brexit is the dismissal of the EU's requirement to treat workers in a civilised manner as "Brussels red tape". As for Trump - the idea that you can dethrone an Establishment run by and for narcissistic billionaires by electing another narcissistic billionaire seems entirely fantastic. If Trump is elected, the US establishment will be happy to do business with him, as usual. Sanders may be a tougher nut to crack, which is why he can't be allowed to win - and why the idea that these candidates "challenge the Establishment" is nonsense, when no Establishment policy is under any serious threat in this election. (Or any other.)
- tomp 11y ago> The Greek debacle was created by the EU's banking and finance industries. No, it was created by the EU who bailed out the banks, paying them money and forcing the loss on the taxpayers. > Most of the scandals were in the banking and finance industries, not - say - the EU parliament. The EU parliament is a scandal in and of itself - "let's waste some money and have two parliament buildings in two cities!"
- tonyedgecombe 11y ago>No, it was created by the EU who bailed out the banks No, it was caused by the Greeks living beyond their means.
- justinhj 11y ago
- tonyedgecombe 11y ago>One of the biggest arguments for the UK leaving the EU is that the EU has become a vast bureaucracy that is remote, bloated, undemocratic, disconnected from the people etc. Except the EU isn't that big, about 33,000 staff [1]. I also seem to remember voting in EU elections so it's hard to call it undemocratic. [1] http://ec.europa.eu/civil_service/docs/hr_key_figures_2016.pdf http://ec.europa.eu/civil_service/docs/hr_key_figures_2016.p...
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoDo you also remember voting for the EU constitution? Or did that get decided for you?
- tonyedgecombe 11y agoIt was democratically rejected: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_establishing_a_Constitution_for_Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_establishing_a_Constitu...
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoAh, my error. I was using the wrong name. Yes, it was democratically rejected... and then replaced by the Treaty of Lisbon, which did most of the same things, and which was done in a way that nobody got to democratically vote on it.
- mike_hearn 11y agoI was trying to reflect the argument as made, rather than saying I agree with it myself. That said, 33k is quite a bit larger than I expected, actually, given that the entire UK civil service is about 10x that size but the EU doesn't do benefits management, tax collection, defence, doesn't run a justice system, transport system, etc. With respect to democracy in Europe, it's a bit complicated. People tend to care a lot more about their national parliaments than the EU parliament. The UK, in particular, gets outvoted in the EU parliament a whole lot, so regardless of what you think of the system in the general sense, for the UK it results in having to do things it doesn't want quite a bit.
- rayiner 11y ago> A big part of Obama's original appeal was his entirely unrealised promise to try and reform Washington. Unfortunately he lost interest in that once elected. Not that he could really have fixed anything anyway: the mismatch between emphasis on the US President and how much power they actually have is kind of ridiculous. I don't think it's fair to say he lost interest in it. It's a combination of 1) having less power than people think; and 2) having to be everyone's President, not just the people who elected him. If you were President and had a good faith desire to govern by national consensus, what would you do? Deregulate industries? Increase regulation? Flat tax? Eliminate social security? Increase social security? Universal healthcare? No healthcare? End the drug war? How much of that do you think would drum up more than bare majority support?
- waterlesscloud 11y agoIt's probably more accurate to say reform was more his marketing hook than his genuine interest in the first place.
- rayiner 11y agoWhy?
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoBecause the questions you're asking (reform how?) were as present on the campaign trail as they are now. If you campaign strongly on "flat tax" or "end the drug war" and are elected then you have your mandate. If you campaign on "hope and change" then it creates the problem you're pointing out -- what is that supposed to mean? Change what?
- FD3SA 11y agoBecause he hired Henry Paulson, the ex-CEO of Goldman Sachs who single handedly devised the entire CDO ponzi scheme, as his Treasury Secretary. For those interested, more here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzrBurlJUNk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzrBurlJUNk Watch the entire documentary, lays it out plain and simple. To this day, not a single prosecution.
- scrumper 11y ago> the mismatch between emphasis on the US President and how much power they actually have is kind of ridiculous. Just to touch on this one point, the situation has its own twisted logic. With this election the concept of the presidency may be entering a new phase where it acts primarily as a lighting rod for disaffection. This effectively helps to strengthen existing power structures in the houses (the parties, ways of working, lobbyists etc.) by focusing popular discontent on a single office.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> A big part of Obama's original appeal was his entirely unrealised promise to try and reform Washington. Unfortunately he lost interest in that once elected. Perhaps more relevantly, it was always he lost the narrow (and unreliable, thanks to a handful of often hostile Democratics) Congressional majority at the first midterm, and it was replaced with an unusually obstructionist opposite-party majority which meant that any Obama policy initiative was dead on arrival. > Not that he could really have fixed anything anyway: the mismatch between emphasis on the US President and how much power they actually have is kind of ridiculous. Candidates often have been very eager to point this out and trying to reflect some of the attention to their Presidential campaign to other avenues (including down-ballot campaigns and maintaining an active grassroot network for their priorities.) But this tends to be ineffectual; people still act like electing a President is all you need to be concerned about, and act surprised when they don't get what they want from doing that alone.