4 ms·
"Error messages" is the usual argument I hear. The article does not address this. I would appreciate an article, why parser generators can or cannot provide err
by qznc 11y ago
"Error messages" is the usual argument I hear. The article does not address this. I would appreciate an article, why parser generators can or cannot provide error messages on par with handwritten parsers.
- haberman 11y agoGood point. I have heard this too and I don't have a deep answer to this question. Maybe someday I'll get to the bottom of it and write a follow-up article. (Article author here).
- user51442 11y agoYears ago I worked on an SML parser that used LR tables, on errors (ie. with no valid transition) it would try to find a symbol to insert/delete/modify that would allow parsing to continue. It dealt reasonably well with simple errors, though ML syntax is a bit flexible - function application is juxtaposition and it has user-defined infix operators (to deal with them, the parser would resolve reduce-reduce and reduce-shift conflicts dynamically by calling a function at runtime). Code is here, in fact: https://github.com/Ravenbrook/mlworks/blob/master/src/parser/_LRparser.sml https://github.com/Ravenbrook/mlworks/blob/master/src/parser...
- ericbb 11y agoHere's one that might interest you. Generating Good Syntax Errors http://research.swtch.com/yyerror http://research.swtch.com/yyerror