3 ms·
Author here. The thing that strikes me here is how something like Reddit Math can fall for the same kinds of 'wisdom of the crowd' things we'd typically see on
by nailer 11y ago
Author here. The thing that strikes me here is how something like Reddit Math can fall for the same kinds of 'wisdom of the crowd' things we'd typically see on Facebook.
Some people like the analogy, so the the math isn't questioned. The post hits reddit's Best Of and more people vote it up. Now it's three months since the post and you'll only notice the error if you collapse the first comment, which is full of praise for the analogy. This is despite Reddit math being a self-selected crowd with a specific interest in the topic.
Note: I originally said 'nobody noticed the error' but as @tzs points out, some users did - collapse the first reply thread and you'll see them.
- erdeszt 11y agoDo you seriously think that anyone would implement crypto based on a reddit post? The lack of mention of modulo multiplication is totally irrelevant for the analogy. You could also say that the box analogy is broken because Eve can take a disc cutter and open the box. Analogies don't have to be perfect duh. I think this is one of the least useful articles I've ever seen on HN.
- nailer 11y ago> Do you seriously think that anyone would implement crypto based on a reddit post? No. I think people may have taken it as a working example of encryption. Evidently it's not. The post in question is also specifically replying to someone asking how Bob and Alice can tell a secret, without Eve knowing. The given example does not do that. > Are you an idiot or do you think everyone else is? This is one of the worst posts I've ever... Have you read: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html yet?
- erdeszt 11y ago>Have you read... Not yet, I've removed the offensive parts. But if you quote from me please quote correctly, your current comment(and the fact that you update it in every 5 minutes) is misleading.
- CPLX 11y agoI agree. The original Reddit post is in fact a quite good shorthand simplification and explanation of the concept. The whole point of simplifying something to an intro level is taking out a bunch of detail so that the most important core premise becomes visible. Adding back the removed detail doesn't change the basic point of the simple explanation it refines it. The OP appears to have fundamentally missed the point.
- tzs 11y ago> Now it's three months since the post and nobody has pointed out the error, despite Reddit math being a self-selected crowd with a specific interest in the topic. /u/GemOfEvan pointed out the error in the second highest (sorted by "Best") reply: I think I'm missing something. Alice has a message m and a product of primes a. She sends Bob the product ma. Bob has the product of primes b and sends back the product mab. Alice divides by a and sends back mb. Eve has heard the products ma, mab, and mb. (ma)(mb)/(mab) = m, so Eve now has the message. Glancing through the other replies, I see at least a half dozen others also pointing out the problem, and also several explaining what it takes to make this kind of three way exchange actually work. Reddit only reports timestamps to the month on articles this old, but all the replies I mention above say "3 months ago".
- misterdata 11y ago> Reddit only reports timestamps to the month on articles this old, but all the replies I mention above say "3 months ago". Hold your mouse over the '3 months ago' and it shows the exact timestamp in a tooltip.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]