3 ms·
Moot?! Please. In 2018 Apple gets handed a national security letter with a demand to backdoor all deployed iOS devices, with which they comply. Users see a r
by ajross 11y ago
Moot?! Please. In 2018 Apple gets handed a national security letter with a demand to backdoor all deployed iOS devices, with which they comply. Users see a routine update (maybe even with some conveniently timed security fixes included too!), and... key in their PIN. Everyone is now backdoored. Not the specific situation you were thinking of? Welcome to the world of security design: holes are everywhere and plugging them piecewise doesn't work if the problem is fundamentally intractable. Your theory would protect the San Bernardino shooters, but not you or me or anyone else.
Why do people (smart people, even!) continue to insist that this problem can be solved by technical measures? This problem cannot be solved technically. Stop it. Please. This misinformation is hurting all of us.
If you want snoop-proof encryption then the user needs to manage the keys herself, which I believe was MJG's point in that blog post. (And even then you're trusting the hardware itself not to have a backdoor to pull off the pass phrase, etc...).
- nickik 11y agoI agree, the general problem can no be solved technically. However I do think its valuable if apple builds the system in a way that forces the state to adopt clunky tools blanked backdoors. At this point the techindusty should have drawn a line and fight for it. Maybe this is Apples strategy. The want to raise the conversation but know they are gone lose this perticular case, so that they have a better position in the next, more important case.