4 ms·
> The judge has indicated skepticism over the government’s demands. Initially, Apple agreed to a formal order to help the Justice Department gain access to Mr.
by pcwalton 11y ago
> The judge has indicated skepticism over the government’s demands. Initially, Apple agreed to a formal order to help the Justice Department gain access to Mr. Feng’s phone, but Judge Orenstein balked, questioning whether the All Writs Act could be used that way. He invited Apple’s lawyers to raise objections.
This is curious, because I was under the impression (due to the lawyers on HN) that this is basically an open and shut case in the eyes of the law: the government has the ability to compel Apple to act. Why would the judge think differently?
(I'm genuinely curious as to the legal aspects of this and not taking a side either way.)
- Laaw 11y ago"The Government" is just a collection of people, and the judicial branch (this judge) is especially distinct from the executive branch (the FBI).
- s_q_b 11y agoIt's tricky. The All Writs Act clearly must have some boundaries as to reasonableness and the due process of the defendant. What Apple is being asked to do here isn't simply to unlock a phone. They're being asked to use their engineers, money, and expertise to build a tool to defeat the very encryption they developed. It's not clear the All Writs Act enables the government to simply order a search warrant recipient to create new technology for them.
- spiralpolitik 11y agoThere is also a first amendment angle in that due to the previous crypto wars code is considered speech so the act of forcing a developer to write code could be considered compelled speech.
- studentrob 11y agoThis is a fantastic point. I hadn't heard that yet, thanks! For the lazy, here's what I found, Compelled speech: http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/compelledspeech.htm http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/compell... Code is free speech: http://archive.arstechnica.com/wankerdesk/2q99/freespeech-1.html http://archive.arstechnica.com/wankerdesk/2q99/freespeech-1....
- s_q_b 11y agoThat's an excellent idea, and certainly a tact I wouldn't initially have considered. Reminds me of this xkcd: http://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/legal_hacks.png http://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/legal_hacks.png
- stock_toaster 11y agofrom wikipedia[1], apparently there is already quite a bit of existing caselaw for the All Writs Act: "In the case U.S. v. New York Telephone Co. 434 U.S. 159 (1977), the Supreme Court established a three-factor test for the admissible application of the All Writs Act: the party ordered to perform an action cannot be too far removed from the case, the government's request cannot impose an undue burden on that party, and the party's assistance is necessary." My guess would be that "undue burden" is probably what the judge is pondering. Possibly "the party's assistance is necessary" (it doesn't say "convenient"!) seems interesting in this case as well, if there are other means to break into the phone (NSA, John McAfee[2]). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Writs_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Writs_Act [2]: https://www.rt.com/news/333326-mcafee-interview-fbi-apple/ https://www.rt.com/news/333326-mcafee-interview-fbi-apple/