10 ms·
Freedom, the US Government, and why Apple are still bad
- bcook 11y ago... is still bad? /grammarnazi
- Redoubts 11y agoThe British tend to use plurals with corporations.
- bcook 11y agoInteresting... the plural says to me "all the individuals at Apple", vs the singular referring to the company as a single, faceless entity. I wonder if that was intended by the author.
- okonomiyaki3000 11y agoSurely not. Just a weird British thing. Like how they write "math" as "maths" and pronounce it "mafs"...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- IBM 11y agoHuh. The fact that Apple are the only ones that can sign software that runs on an iPhone may just allow them to defeat the DoJ in court. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-02-24/apple-fbi-fight-asks-is-code-protected-as-free-speech http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-02-24/apple-fbi-... Apple has indicated that they're going to continue to keep increasing the security of their products in the future, which may make it impossible to update firmware to the Secure Enclave (or at least require the user's permission first), but that's actually a weak measure. I'm not sure why tech people think that technical means to accomplish zero knowledge is the holy grail, that will never trump having the law on your side. Congress could pass legislation (like CALEA for tech companies) that would require everyone to design their products to make them accessible to law enforcement any time they want.
- spiralpolitik 11y agoAt this point you might as well kiss goodbye to the US tech industry as nobody overseas will by anything that has a US government mandated backdoored.
- IBM 11y agoI'm pretty sure if Congress passes legislation mandating it they can influence plenty of non-American businesses by withholding their ability to do business in the US.
- gboudrias 11y agoThereby gaining... what exactly?
- IBM 11y agoLaw enforcement access in exchange for access to the biggest and wealthiest market in the world.
- throwaway2048 11y agoIf they don't buy American products? I don't think so.
- IBM 11y agoDo any of those businesses want to sell their products to Americans? Maybe they can sell different SKUs with those capabilities but they'll have to do it for every market they sell to because the US won't be the only government that will want backdoors.
- pjc50 11y agoIndeed. This already works the other way round: companies selling into China have to comply with their "great firewall" requirements.
- zekevermillion 11y agoWhose logo is on your i-thing? Render unto Apple the things that are Apple's, and keep private what is truly private in the first place. If you'll forgive the abuse of an old parable...
- thothamon 11y agoI agree with all the ideas in the article, but at a bare minimum, Apple should configure devices so that no firmware update can be installed unless the user enters their PIN first. This would be an easy move that would make this whole debate moot. The problem is that Apple only partially protected users from Apple itself.
- teacup50 11y agoThere's a much bigger elephant in the room, though: Updates to the OS and applications are encrypted, completely opaque, signed by Apple instead of the original developer, can be granted additional entitlements for arbitrary permissions, and cannot be audited by anyone but Apple without a jailbreak. When coupled with push updates, Apple already has a targeted backdoor into every iPhone anywhere connected the network. This is a much more difficult problem to solve, as securing against that threat model requires an diverse ecosystem of 3rd-party audit/review, software, and tools. I don't see any way of solving that issue while also maintaining their stranglehold on the platform via DRM.
- ikeboy 11y agoDon't users need to confirm OTA updates?
- saurik 11y agoThis person is talking about for applications, to which many users have "automatic updates" turned on; this is one of the places where Android is fundamentally by design more secure than iOS (though by implementation has often been weaker :/ see the Master Key family of vulnerabilities).
- ikeboy 11y agoAh. Missed that point. What's the highest permission an app can have? Wouldn't that be the limit of the vulnerability here? Also, many permissions require manual granting, e.g. contacts, camera. Edit: also, that could be mitigated partly by requiring user approval of any updates adding permissions.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- upofadown 11y agoI don't have anything against Apple retaining control of the firmware on an Apple phone. It is their closed system after all. It's just that Apple should not imply that their phones are somehow secure. The FBI thing reminds us that they are all effectively backdoored by Apple.
- pjc50 11y agoOn this topic I have a large unfinished essay: https://github.com/pjc50/pjc50.github.io/blob/master/pentagram-control.md https://github.com/pjc50/pjc50.github.io/blob/master/pentagr...