5 ms·
Interesting, I think I always subvocalise when reading and found it hard not to when I just tried. I just asked my wife and she says she never hears a voice or
by simonh 11y ago
Interesting, I think I always subvocalise when reading and found it hard not to when I just tried. I just asked my wife and she says she never hears a voice or even music in her head like that and was a bit shocked when I said I could.
When I was a teenager I took elocution lessons, read poetry and acted in plays. I would read through a piece imagining where I would pause, where to put emphasis, etc. So I know I subvocalised then, but don't know if I did before or if that's when I learned to do it.
I know it takes me much longer to read a book than my brother or father or many of my friends. I can read a book once and remember small details from the story they have completely forgotten and sometimes they've read a book multiple times when I have far better recollection of it from a single much slower reading. I'm wondering if subvocalisation plays a part in that.
Edit: another factor is that I remember words from their sound, not their spelling, so have always had difficulty with spelling. I can't visualise the word, and often need to actualy write a word out before I can figure out how to spell it. Just spelling out words letter by letter vocally is very hard for me.
- hosh 11y agoI've have experience with both reading with sound and not reading with sound. When I drop the sound when I read, it stays a stream of concepts, and I can read fast. On the other hand, it also drops pretty much all of the emotional nuances. I don't read much poetry, but I don't think it makes much sense to read it without a voice. I don't think I have tried typing without voicing things out, except maybe when I'm writing code. I don't read without vocalizing in my head much anymore. I found that without hearing that, my EQ in relation to communicating with a person drops. On the other hand, if I'm visualizing some systems interactions in my head, it's not going to be verbalized. Until maybe, I try to explain it to someone.
- dibujante 11y agoFunny that you bring up spelling. I have absolutely no subvocalisation when reading and have always been an impeccable speller. When I read, I have trouble with fiction because I can't imagine pauses, emphasis, or any other non-textual cues in dialogue. I read a lot of non-fiction.
- lfowles 11y ago> I have absolutely no subvocalisation when reading and have always been an impeccable speller. I'm also an impeccable speller and I attribute that to my brain somehow leapfrogging past sounding out words to recognizing them by shape. Not certain if I subvocalize, but I do have an internal reader.
- newman314 11y agoInteresting. I do subvocalize but my memory is terrible. The best way I can describe it is that I have a inaccurate lookup table so I can kind of remember things but recalling specific things is hard particularly when I need the information. I don't usually have issues with spelling though. So I end up using a ton of Google and obsessively taking notes/making lists. Quip has been a lifesaver.
- djKianoosh 11y agoI'm the exact same. I prefer to "hear" the voice in the writing as it helps me understand (but not necessarily remember every detail). How do you use quip?
- newman314 11y agoI like Quip because it's multi platform shared note taking. I use it to generate todos (different notes for different subjects), lists and scratch for developing ideas/documents. For example, I've been working on a security primer for internal consumption. The output will get turned into a presentation eventually. Quip makes it easy to invite a colleague to collaborate.
- drivers99 11y agoI also subvocalize what I read which slows me down, but also helps me remember, I think. My eyes can read faster but if they get ahead of the sound, I will get tripped up and have to backtrack. I also subvocalize my thoughts as one-way discussions in my head with people I know. But that made me remember/realize that I sometimes imagine someone I know reading what I am reading, which I think incorporates even more brain circuits in order to memorize it, although that's not why I do that. I don't choose to do any of those things; it's involuntary. I also enjoy rewatching movies with people who haven't seen it. I put myself in their position in my head and experience it from (what I think is) their perspective.