2 ms·
"When there are only one thousand people, you still expect those who grew up in such an environment will still somehow manage a fertility rate of 1.0?" OK, so
by mikeash 11y ago
"When there are only one thousand people, you still expect those who grew up in such an environment will still somehow manage a fertility rate of 1.0?"
OK, so you're going to declare that not only will fertility drop way lower than it is today, but that even in a hypothetical future where overpopulation is not a problem it must continue to drop.
And somehow my ideas are "miracles" but your ideas are obviously true.
I get the impression you're not actually open to ideas on this.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y ago> but that even in a hypothetical future where overpopulation is not a problem it must continue to drop. This supposes that population is currently dropping because of overpopulation. I see no evidence of that. China is your best candidate as a counterexample, and it falls flat. They've rescinded the one child policy. If you are right, fertility should climb there... but the initial indications are that a people trained to be low-fertility continue to be low-fertility even after the training stops. I'm not exactly shocked.