5 ms·
University courses? I'm pretty sure CPUs were a huge part of my first year of CS.
by toyg 11y ago
University courses? I'm pretty sure CPUs were a huge part of my first year of CS.
- Someone1234 11y agoMe too, but there's a huge gap between the often simplified CPUs they teach you on at Uni' and programming for the querks in x86, or any of the buses/peripherals/interfaces. I didn't learn much more than assembly 101. I doubt I could emulate much real hardware. Certainly not a PC of all things... A gameboy looks more accessible...
- mhurron 11y agoWow, advocating higher education on HN. Feeling bold today?
- toyg 11y agoI've not really enjoyed my time in higher-ed (and I have little to show for it), but sometimes it's really the only place where unfashionable but fundamental topics are covered in depth. My comment was meant as a pointer (i.e. "check out lecture recordings etc") rather than a quip.
- ohRightForgot 11y agoReally? Because it sounded exactly like a snarky troll.
- 0xffff2 11y agoLearning about CPU internals was a huge part of your first year in CS? Where did you go to school? At my school and every other school I'm remotely familiar with, the knowledge needed to emulate a CPU would be covered in upper division computer engineering courses, and not covered by CS undergrads at all, certainly not in their first year.
- khedoros 11y agoI got a solid understanding of CPU operations in my undergraduate computer architectures class, in my CS degree. Of course, it was probably a third year class. First year sounds a little unusual.
- toyg 11y agoBologna, Italy (from the school of Science, not Engineering). At the time (16+ years ago, under prof. Renzo Davoli), the introductory "Computer Architecture" course [1] was almost entirely dedicated to CPU architecture, including building basic ones (IIRC). To be fair, I did drop out a year later :) [1] http://www.unibo.it/en/teaching/degree-programmes/study-plan/2015/8009 http://www.unibo.it/en/teaching/degree-programmes/study-plan...
- jcoffland 11y agoThis kind of course (computer architecture) is typical of the cross CS/EE requirements and can usually be taken during any year of an undergraduate degree in CS. Prerequisites are minimal if any.
- danjayh 11y agoI taught that class once. It does have some prerequisites, but not a ton. I think it could be taken as early as second year, first semester at that particular school.
- Elv13 11y agoBack in 2007, my first semester in a technical CS school had plenty of assembly, binary, MMU emulation, OSI / TCP/IP, boolean math and so on. I know this is mostly gone at this point, but it should not. The fundamentals are essentials. I often meet people who are totally clueless how a computer work and have CS degrees. "How can you do C, it is so old? By now, we must have invented faster languages. Computers changed so much recently". Sure... Binary is now expressed with emoji.
- 11y ago
- shinymark 11y ago0xffff2 - I can't reply directly to you for some reason but I went to UC Berkeley many years ago and the third undergrad course, CS 61C, laid the basic groundwork for beginning to understand CPUs. Here's the syllabus from the most recent semester. http://www-inst.eecs.berkeley.edu/~cs61c/sp16/ http://www-inst.eecs.berkeley.edu/~cs61c/sp16/
- toomanybeersies 11y agoWhat university did you go to? My university didn't touch on hardware until the second half of second year, and that was only one paper (strictly speaking, a computer engineering paper).