3 ms·
The increasing political divide in the US is the direct result of ever more aggressive gerrymandering. Jurisdictions are becoming ever more partisan. So now on
by specialist 11y ago
The increasing political divide in the US is the direct result of ever more aggressive gerrymandering.
Jurisdictions are becoming ever more partisan. So now only the most partisan (divisive) candidates can win their primary election, which then pretty much makes the general election moot.
The fix is California style redistricting, where citizens and not politicians are in charge of the process.
- bgilroy26 11y agoEconomic uncertainty is also bad for solidarity. It becomes a "Team up? What for?" situation
- jarjoura 11y agoThat's definitely a cause for what we're seeing out of Congress, but it's not related to what we're seeing with Trump. He is winning at the polls with his hateful angry rhetoric and it's pretty damn strange.
- specialist 11y agoCaucus results are determined by the handful of people who bother to show up. Trump's winning because his supporters are showing up. This speaks more to the failings of the other candidates than the success of Trump.
- bryondowd 11y agoNot familiar with 'California style redistricting' and I'm curious. Have a short explanation or a link?
- specialist 11y agoSure thing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Citizens_Redistricting_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Citizens_Redistrict...
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The increasing political divide in the US is the direct result of ever more aggressive gerrymandering. I think that there is almost precisely zero evidence of this; there's a lot more to support that regional strong political divides have always been present in the US, what's new is that the salient issues have become increasingly consistent nationally, so that it is no more the case that the national political scene often seems less sharply divided because all the sharp regional divides used to be in different places, whereas now there are more common national divides. > The fix is California style redistricting, where citizens and not politicians are in charge of the process. Non/bipartisan redistricting by notionally independent commissions (which, often, as in California, legislators actually have a role in choosing members for, so they aren't truly independent of the legislators, though they are certainly less accountable than legislators) has been a growing trend in the same time as the increasing polarization in national politics. So, its pretty clearly not fixing the problem.