4 ms·
The reality is that Apple already has unfettered access to this device: they left themselves a backdoor to which only they have the key, in the form of a "secur
by saurik 11y ago
The reality is that Apple already has unfettered access to this device: they left themselves a backdoor to which only they have the key, in the form of a "secure" update mechanism that is so "secure" that even the user can't control it, only Apple can. To me the actual question here is whether the FBI should be allowed to ask and then force Apple to use the backdoor Apple built into their product; Apple painting this as if they are being asked to build a backdoor instead of use an existing one is them being nothing more than dishonest in an attempt to twist the story and shift the blame. So yes: I think it is fair to describe the security of this device, from the perspective of Apple, as nothing more than a ribbon, as Apple already has "unfettered access to [your] data". Apple trusts users so little that they don't give users control of the hardware they own... this is frankly a good lesson on them that this is responsibility they should never have hoarded. "Here's hoping that the iPhone 7 no longer has a backdoor that is controlled by Apple."
- acqq 11y ago> from the perspective of Apple, as nothing more than a ribbon, as Apple already has "unfettered access to [your] data" No! Since iOS8 Apple intentionally encrypts the user's data on the phone in a way that even they don't have access to them. They have access to the hardware, to be able to reconfigure it, but not the encrypted data on the phone. Because the data is encrypted, intentionally so. And they have access to the iCloud backup data and they gave that data to the FBI. Then FBI actually locked their access to the phone by changing the iCloud password.
- saurik 11y agoThis is an iPhone 5C, which does not have the "secure enclave" feature, and it isn't even clear helps as Apple has stated to reporters that it is possible to do what the FBI wants, so we know the software on that component must be mutable. If it was actually impossible to do the thing the FBI wanted them to do then we would not even be having this discussion today: Apple would just say "can't, sorry" and the FBI would be forced to move on with their lives as nothing Apple could do would help them get access to the device.
- acqq 11y agoSecure Enclave is irrelevant here. Even without Secure Enclave the data on iPhone 5C is encrypted with the user's password and Apple doesn't have access to the data as it doesn't have user's password, contrary to your claim that "Apple has the access to the data." No, FBI has access, but only to the encrypted data. And FBI can't decrypt it. They locked themselves out of the phone, actually. And the phone is not the private phone of the killer, he destroyed that one, and his computer too. And note that he didn't care about this phone. FBI demands from Apple to change their product (iOS) to make the encryption cracking attempts by FBI easier.
- saurik 11y agoIt takes mere minutes for us to crack the 4- digit passcode on the iPhone 4 (which I only specify as that's where we were last able to easily do this in the jailbreak community; it might be faster now), and most people likely don't use terribly strong passwords; the FBI might also have "leads" on what the password is, but not good enough ones that they feel confident dealing with ten attempts. This is a backdoor to the lock: you can quibble with me over the definition of "unfettered" (I do not consider "it will take some time, but I absolutely have a 100% chance of getting access without fail" terribly "fettered", but it definitely is more than the people who are frustrated with this situation seem to want the FBI to have). > FBI demands from Apple to change their product (iOS) to make the encryption cracking attempts by FBI easier. ... and we should be thankful the FBI didn't simply demand the 4096-bit key Apple uses to sign firmwares, because that's all they actually need--nothing more than 512 bytes of data--in order to accomplish the thing everyone is upset about here.
- acqq 11y ago> It takes mere minutes for us to crack the 4- digit passcode on the iPhone 4 Please make it then for iPhone 5C. You would do the world a favor. If you claim you don't have the needed RSA key, then you confirm that the encryption actually works. And you know that your "tool" wouldn't work on the copy of the encrypted data, too. Nice for consumers, isn't it, hardware-dependent functioning encryption by Apple.
- camillomiller 11y agoThis is completely upside down. Can all Apple haters for once put down their haters' hat and try and be reasonable for the good of everybody? You phrased all that just to get to the conclusion that Apple is an over-controlling company imposing rules on otherwise super tech savvy users. Well sorry to break the news for you, but people decide on their own which smartphone to buy. Globally, most of the time, it's an Android phone. Globally, most of the time, it's an OLD and cheap Android phone, with firmwares so old and so full of holes that calling it insecure would be an euphemism. But hey, I suppose they're much better off, since they can DECIDE what phone to buy, right? It's certainly not their income deciding for them... Better, they can even root it! Make it even more insecure! Install pirated software that hides malware and will steal their ids or their money! Now THAT's choice and power to the user!
- zer01 11y agoDon't pigeon-hole yourself, most people just want a phone that can load facebook and is cheap. The number of people who care about security is definitely rising, but they're still in a fairly small minority. Also I'd venture that Saurik is quite the opposite of an "Apple hater", as he created cydia (https://cydia.saurik.com/ https://cydia.saurik.com/), and contributed arguably the most to the iphone jailbreak community to date.
- saurik 11y agoAs long as you don't care if someone can attempt to pull the data from your phone like this, then sure: go ahead and buy that phone. The people generally in these threads, however, and apparently the opinion of Apple itself, is that the FBI should not be able to get the data off of this device; as it stands, Apple can guarantee their eventual success. > Better, they can even root it! Make it even more insecure! Install pirated software that hides malware and will steal their ids or their money! Now THAT's choice and power to the user! This makes no sense. Sure: someone can make their device less secure if they want. I absolutely support you doing that. They can also try to use vulnerabilities to take back control of their device and make it more secure (though with an iPhone there are some serious issues with this, due to how almost impossible it is to lock Apple out). But what does this have to do with the conversation at hand? Can you connect any of this back with the FBI discussion?
- NEDM64 11y agoSure. It's a Backdoor that only you and Apple know of. Right?
- saurik 11y agoNo: it is a backdoor that everyone in the world knows of, including the FBI, which is why this is even a question. Apple is the only party allowed to change the software running on the device, using their software update encryption key: this is a backdoor into at least this device (an iPhone 5C).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zer01 11y agoFair points, though to be fair the iOS platform is by and large the most secure mobile platform we have (please correct me if I'm wrong, you absolutely know better than I). Still, as long as the backdoor remains, it will always be possible to carry out malicious updates like this. As far as I understand the secure enclave has been updated a couple times since it's introduction, so I legitimately hope this was a v1, with secure enclave v2 (without update functionality) waiting to be released in Sept. As a side-note - one of the things I struggle with is I'm not convinced that Apple really had a tangible reason to make it as secure as it is, especially when their main competition was android, which is fairly laughable with security thanks to the OEMs.
- saurik 11y agoI think Apple in general and Tim Cook in specific are highly moral people: I think they are truly looking at security as a way to make the world a better place; in discussions I have had with employees at Apple, they truly do attempt to build systems where even they don't have access to your information... only at the same time, but somehow from the other side of their mouth, when questioned about their ability to do things that are evil when they do have that ability, they just say "well, we'd never do that", and refuse to discuss scenarios where "we" is difficult to define (as it only takes a finite number of disgruntled employees to decide to do something bad) or they are forced by external parties (such as the United States government). I'm honestly kind of glad to see that latter scenario actually play out, and particularly to see it play out so publicly, so we can see how they react as "well, we'd never do that" even has the possibility of turning into "fuck, we were forced to do that".
- zer01 11y agoAgreed, I'm extremely glad this is being done in such a public fashion. It's important to have transparency about these issues.
- brbsix 11y agoDoesn't the secure update mechanism simply permit access to the system partition? This late in the game, how can that possibly give Apple user filesystem keys? Those require the PIN or password. An OS update at this point can only permit rapid brute force iteration. Obviously "unfettered access to the device" is really useful to steal user keys while the device is unlocked, but it's not so helpful after the fact.
- saurik 11y ago> Obviously "unfettered access to the device" is really useful to steal user keys while the device is unlocked, but it's not so helpful after the fact. Exactly: the ability for Apple to send a specific user a different firmware update than they send everyone else is extremely brutal and there is absolutely no way the user (no matter how intelligent) could even tell that they were being targeted as the only person who has even remotely powerful access to the firmware being loaded is Apple themselves. > This late in the game, how can that possibly give Apple user filesystem keys? Those require the PIN or password. You just brute force this. On the iPhone 4 it took minutes to brute force a 4- digit PIN code, and clearly it wouldn't be a challenge to brute force a 6- digit PIN code (this is still less than a day). If the user has a password, it might take a while (depending on how good it is), but it is still a guaranteed attack. You can quibble with me on the definition of "unfettered", but I maintain that "will take (maybe) some time but almost no effort to get a 100% success rate, and which will complete almost certainly before the statute of limitations expires on the crime" is not usefully "fettered".
- pfg 11y agoI don't think this is a fair assessment. Apple is being asked to create a firmware version without brute force rate-limiting. With a sufficiently complex passphrase, the FBI is still SOL. They're not being asked to create a firmware version that would decrypt the disk - which would be impossible due to the iPhone's security architecture. The fact that only Apple is in a position to sign firmware that could do this is a positive thing in this context. The only alternatives are no firmware signing at all (so everyone could run this attack), no updates at all, or enforcing the rate-limiting in a HSM (which is what they're doing on the latest generation iPhones).
- saurik 11y ago> Apple is being asked to create a firmware version without brute force rate-limiting. This is a one line of code change for Apple and would take them a few minutes. FWIW, there are people in the iOS jailbreaking community who could do this without the source code rather quickly. I'll even go so far as to say that we actually already have all the tools for this lying around for the iPhone 4, and with only minimal changes made by even less qualified engineers they would probably work on the iPhone 5C. > With a sufficiently complex passphrase, the FBI is still SOL. Most people use the 4- or 6- digit PIN number. One presumes that in this case the user did so (and you can tell, as the UI is different depending on the kind of passphrase used), or the FBI wouldn't be quite so excited to bother here. It takes mere minutes to crack a 4- digit PIN code on the iPhone 4. > The fact that only Apple is in a position to sign firmware that could do this is a positive thing in this context. The only alternatives are no firmware signing at all (so everyone could run this attack), no updates at all, or enforcing the rate-limiting in a HSM (which is what they're doing on the latest generation iPhones). You have conveniently removed "allow the user to lock everyone out from firmware updates except themselves" from the list of possible options :/. While I am perfectly happy with the idea that some people might want to allow Apple to update the firmware on their device, I would much rather no one be able to do that unless they go through me, and as I own the hardware and it is my data that is on the line, I should have the right to make that decision. Apple is selling locks, claiming them to be secure, while not only sitting on a master key but now claiming that it isn't really a master key, which is not just disingenuous but outright dishonest at this point.
- rrego 11y agoMore or less correct if fully trusting any signed code by a third party (Apple) is a backdoor. For what it's worth, signed code imparts security benefits to Apple and Android users who indeed can't be trusted to not screw up their own phones. Thing is, this entire system is based off of trust. If people lose trust in Apple, then they lose trust product. While even Apple can't decrypt the data, existence of malicious signed code means you can't trust signed code. FBI would have done better to ask Apple in secret. Apple really made the only possible choice when faced with a public request.
- saurik 11y ago> FBI would have done better to ask Apple in secret. Apple really made the only possible choice when faced with a public request. I agree. I will go further and say that I hope Apple would make the same decision in secret. I believe Apple in general and Tim Cook in particular to be not just moral, but "principled", in that I feel like he's unlikely to back down from a moral argument without being beaten into submission. I hope Apple fights this one to the death. > Thing is, this entire system is based off of trust. If people lose trust in Apple, then they lose trust product. While even Apple can't decrypt the data, existence of malicious signed code means you can't trust signed code. The question at hand is whether it makes sense to trust a company when their government wants them to do something and may technically have the law (as broken as you or I or even "almost everyone" feels that law is) on their side. This is the same discussion about putting data on servers in other countries run by companies that might bow to the will of some oppressive totalitarian regime, only the server is in your pocket and the regime is the United States through the FBI.
- zer01 11y agoSigning code can only do so much. What Apple possesses is the somewhat unique ability to design a system that is actually secure by burning the key into the secure enclave and not allowing it to be updated. The only way someone would be able to get to it then is by attacking the physical hardware itself (which I'm sure an NSA-level attacker could do), but it would render this entire thing moot, as even Apple wouldn't be able to unlock the phone if it wanted. I say unique because they can bake security into the actual hardware design, and tightly control how the entire thing works, which android & windows simply can't do. In order to trust your OS (and in turn, your signed software), you have to trust your hardware first. The security of the entire system falls apart if you can't trust your hardware.