4 ms·
I'll read the rest, but I see you suggest civil asset forfeiture is Constitutional. What your quote seems to describe is not the modern asset forfeiture, where
by unethical_ban 11y ago
I'll read the rest, but I see you suggest civil asset forfeiture is Constitutional.
What your quote seems to describe is not the modern asset forfeiture, where cash and goods are seized without the person being charged with a crime. And I doubt Madison had "United States v. $25,000" in mind when considering the permissions of the federal government to take property.
- rayiner 11y agoRead Boyd, pages 623-24. It is talking precisely about the United States v. $25,000 sort of cases, where property is seized because it is contraband or otherwise subject to forfeiture, not as punishment for a crime. The opinion refers to the "first statute passed by Congress to regulate the collection of duties, the act of July 31, 1789, 1 Stat. 29, 43" which deals with seizure of imported contraband without charging anyone of a crime. Boyd distinguishes those justified seizures from the seizures of documents at issue in the case on the basis that "[in] the one case, the government is entitled to the possession of the property; in the other it is not." One cannot have a legitimate property right in contraband or the fruits of illegal activity, so seizure thereof does not violate due process. The problem with modern asset forfeiture (which I think is constitutional, but still a bad idea), is not due process, but probability. Finding untaxed sugar on a ship carries high indicia of reliability as to the conclusion it is contraband subject to forfeiture. That's less true for $25,000 found in someone's car trunk (though statistically, that's highly likely to be fruits of illegal activity as well).