4 ms·
50% of Americans can only take the opposite stance if they know what stance they are taking. The reporting on the poll doesn't reveal any screening questions to
by zepto 11y ago
50% of Americans can only take the opposite stance if they know what stance they are taking. The reporting on the poll doesn't reveal any screening questions to determine whether the respondents understand the issues at stake. If they don't understand the issue, then the 50% is answering a question about something else.
If they asked the question "Should Apple make it easier for terrorists and foreign hackers to access information on American phones", I suspect less than 50% would say yes.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoComplying with the FBI's request does not make it easier for terrorists and foreign hackers to access data on American phones. This is a case where having a little bit of knowledge leads to a wildly inaccurate conclusion, similar to Greenwald's original PRISM reporting.
- Spivak 11y agoIt sure does if that signed malicious firmware ever got out. And it will eventually since once it's written it will be requested by every police department and federal agency for ever increasing trivial cases. Every government in the world will want access to that piece of code. If Apple really can tie the firmware to a specific piece of hardware with no possibility of it being modified I would be impressed but even still a little cautious.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoThe FBI has given Apple the option of brute-forcing the phone for them. In that case, the build never leaves Apple, just like the build that Apple has previously used to extract unencrypted data from iPhones. Making the build not-modifiable is easy. That's what's stopping the FBI from modifying the existing build to remove the wipe rule.
- oldmanjay 11y agoWhere do you get the idea Apple made a special build to extract unencrypted data?
- lern_too_spel 11y agoBecause the standard build does not have the capability to bypass the lock screen and extract data.
- zepto 11y agoWhat makes you think such a build has been used before?
- lern_too_spel 11y agoThat Apple has said so in their transparency reports.
- oldmanjay 11y agoI can't find any statements indicating this required a special build, just normal access to the storage. If you have some citation for this I'd appreciate it.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoOn the standard build, normal access to storage only works if you've unlocked the phone.
- wooter 11y ago> Complying with the FBI's request does not make it easier for terrorists and foreign hackers to access data on American phones. You're disagreeing with every cyber security researcher I know, as well as the EFF, with no sources at all. At least google the subject.