4 ms·
If Apple can do something that will unencrypt the phone, then obviously the vulnerability is already present. How about Apple hacks the phone, then fixes the vu
by cortesoft 11y ago
If Apple can do something that will unencrypt the phone, then obviously the vulnerability is already present. How about Apple hacks the phone, then fixes the vulnerability so they can't do it again in the future?
- matheweis 11y agoThe analysis I have read from those that understand the technicalities behind it better than I do is that it is because the phone in question is a 5C. e.g. Apple has already fixed the holes in the 6/6S; the concern here is the use of all writs to compel them to unlock the 5C, and the Pandora's box that doing so would open up.
- tantalor 11y agoNo, the devices with secure enclave (like 6/6S) are just as exploitable by the phonemaker. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160218/10371233643/yes-backdoor-that-fbi-is-requesting-can-work-modern-iphones-too.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160218/10371233643/yes-b...
- matheweis 11y agoUgh, if Rob Graham and Bruce Schnier can't be used as a good source... Sounds like Apple needs to update Secure Enclave so that updating wipes the keys.
- vectorjohn 11y agoYep, exactly. If they did that, and the government was trying to somehow make that illegal, or demand a real backdoor, then it would be time to get up in arms. But that time is not yet.
- nxzero 11y agoHow does this fix the issue? NY alone has said they will request Apple unlock roughly 200 phones they already have, so please explain how this is a solution.
- rhino369 11y ago>NY alone has said they will request Apple unlock roughly 200 phones they already have, so please explain how this is a solution Why is this a problem? As long as the government has the legal right to search the phone, isn't it good that they can now search it? Remember this would only apply to phones the government has physical control over and in cases where Apple is compelled by a court.
- Diederich 11y ago> Remember this would only apply to phones the government has physical control over and in cases where Apple is compelled by a court. I'm curious how we can be certain of that. Granted, this is the 'slippery slope' argument. A lot of people, myself included, don't think the government is interested in ONLY decrypting phones in this class. They want to decrypt ALL of them, en masse, at will. The hell of it is, as I typed the above, I think of how I would have felt reading those words typed by someone else, 15 years ago. I'd assume they were some kind of conspiracy nut.
- rhino369 11y agoHow else would the FBI compel Apple to do it? If there is some other way, why does doing it the legal way make the illegal way more likely?
- nxzero 11y agoThat's the point, they legally can't make Apple do it.
- nxzero 11y agoAgree, as stated, 15 years ago someone would have thought "nut job" - funny (read crazy) thing is now that the general public switched from believing this was crazy to it making sense.
- nxzero 11y agoAgree, as stated 15 years ago someone would have thought "nut job" - funny (read crazy) thing is now that the general public switched from believing this was crazy to it making sense.
- tantalor 11y agoThey have that ability because they (and only they) can update the OS. So, "fixing that vulnerability" prevents them from ever updating the OS again. You're better off security-wise accepting their updates.
- icebraining 11y agoWhy? If one can only upgrade the OS with a package signed by Apple, why couldn't it check for a second signature, generated from the user's password? Then you could upgrade the OS, you'd just need the user's password.
- sp332 11y agoApple can't decrypt the phone. All they can do is make it easier to brute-force the password. If the firmware is cooperating and not introducing artificial delays, you can try one password every 80 ms. In later versions of the phone, the hardware enforces a 5-second delay which you might not be able to work around even with cooperative firmware.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoSomething much worse is possible. What if the NSA/CIA/whoever can already decrypt that phone if they want? What if they're very publicly showing limitations of their abilities that aren't real, so that bad guys use it as a manual ("follow these steps and the NSA can't spy on us", except they actually can)? What if they're doing this so that bad guys (as defined by them) continue to use and trust vulnerable systems, rather than looking for secure alternatives? If that scenario is right, if all this is just theater, then Apple will eventually win this fight, and along the way, there will be pretty clear guidelines established about what the NSA currently can and cannot break. Only you can't trust that what gets revealed is accurate...
- Nadya 11y agoAh, the ol' COINTEL conspiracy (I use that word without its usual negative connotation). I'm always surprised by people's ability to assume "the Government isn't corrupt this time!" after time and time and time and time (and time and time)... and time... and time... and time again, the Government was "that corrupt that time". While it should never be assumed that they for certain are, it should always remain a possibility until reasonably argued against. Of course, one can't prove a negative - so the line of where it has been "reasonably argued against" is a very gray area. It's easy to cross the line into "full-blown looney conspiracist". Which, going along the COINTEL mindset, is exactly what a Government would want: The general population dismissing anyone critical of the government as being a looney nutcase...because the Government couldn't possibly be corrupt. As someone who has read too much into COINTEL operations and literature (and at one point wanted to right a book about various COINTEL tactics) - it's really hard to dismiss ideas like the one you bring up - even on grounds of "there's no evidence for that".