3 ms·
...and harvesting those plants kills millions of rodents per section. A plant diet is quite arguably more devastating to animal life than a meat one.
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
...and harvesting those plants kills millions of rodents per section. A plant diet is quite arguably more devastating to animal life than a meat one.
- DanBC 11y ago> A plant diet is quite arguably more devastating to animal life than a meat one. No, a person could not credibly make that argument. Don't forget that the meat-providing animals have to eat plant material. So you have the same problems of the vegan diet, plus the inefficiency of the plant-to-meat conversion, plus killing of the meat animals.
- unprepare 11y agoor you still have the exact same singular problem: You kill things in order to survive. Full stop. Meat eaters, vegans, pescatarians, vegetarians, whatever - they all survive by killing other living things and consuming them. I was wondering the opinion of someone who was making good passionate arguments against the consumption of meat on the basis that it is immoral to kill and eat living things. I guess wondering how that user feels about this philosophical quandary is downvote worthy though
- noondip 11y agoThe definition of veganism is, a way of living which seeks to exclude, as far as is possible and practicable, all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose. It's not about pursuing some ideal in which no one gets hurt. It's also ludicrous to argue that "killing" plants is in any way comparable to killing actual animals. Check out this site, it very accurately and in a straightforward manner discredits all of the arguments you've made against veganism in this thread so far - http://adaptt.org/veganism.html# http://adaptt.org/veganism.html#
- unprepare 11y agoI'm responding directly to an argument based on it being morally wrong to kill living things, specifically to kill some living things but not others (cows but not golden retrievers). I am not making arguments against veganism, i am asking a philosophical question in response to a moral position. Please understand i am not attacking you or your lifestyle My argument was, again, how do you use a moral justification of 'killing things is wrong' to change from one lifestyle of killing things, to another lifestyle of killing different things? Why is cow vs golden retriever so important, but golden retriever vs potato completely laughable? You are still ending life to nourish your body no matter what. Both a cow and a potato cause and have external costs as well (i would say methane from cows is less or equally concerning as pesticides)
- noondip 11y ago> Why is cow vs golden retriever so important, but golden retriever vs potato completely laughable? You are still ending life to nourish your body no matter what. This is what Jainists believe and they actually avoid root vegetables for this reason. I'd like to see you make the same argument for fruit, for example. Do you think "killing" a fruit is the same as killing a cow? Do you really think a fruit's life is "ended" when I bite into it? If so, you're just appealing to ridicule and I'm not sure this conversation is worth having. > i would say methane from cows is less or equally concerning as pesticides The methane emitted from cattle farming is literally one of the largest contributors to climate change. To say it's less concerning than the use of pesticides shows a deep ignorance of the contradicting evidence, or confusion.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoBut there used to be millions of buffalo roaming the American Midwest. They produced methane too. So this isn't some new issue, right?
- unprepare 11y ago>I'd like to see you make the same argument for fruit, for example. Why is cow vs golden retriever so important, but golden retriever vs apple completely laughable? You are still ending life to nourish your body no matter what. Oh and i doubt you will have that opinion if bees are eradicated worldwide due to pesticides and we all die off
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoA cow grazing a pasture is not killing the mice in that pasture. Its true that winter fodder (hay) requires cutting the field (three times over the summer). But that isn't the same as plowing, planting, cultivating and for some crops, digging to harvest. So grass-fed beef is absolutely several orders of magnitude less devastating to animal life. One cow is killed to feed several people. Instead of millions of rodents killed to provide potatoes.
- DanBC 11y agoBeef cows need very much more food than pasture grazing.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoNot around here. In Iowa, they're grass fed for most of their lives.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- noondip 11y agoThe worldwide premeditated killings of 60 billion land animals in slaughterhouses and 90 billion marine animals in the waterways are diametrically opposed to the accidental tractor-killings in a field. Slaughterhouses intentionally kill animals for meat, dairy and egg-eaters. How many farmers do you know intentionally crushing gophers, mice and snakes with their John Deeres?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoEvery single mouse, snake and gopher in the field is killed by plowing, spraying, cultivating and harvesting. By the millions per section. The ground under the shade of a field of corn is essentially sterile. Enough denial; its absolutely disastrous to animal life to farm vegetables and grains.
- 11y ago