3 ms·
I do not have my PhD yet. Yet I am clearly inside the academic system because I am at a university. A PhD is a researcher merit badge. Obtaining it means you'v
by scott_s 17y ago
I do not have my PhD yet. Yet I am clearly inside the academic system because I am at a university.
A PhD is a researcher merit badge. Obtaining it means you've been trained by people in your field how to do research. I have real difficulty calling anyone working on their PhD, or anyone who has a PhD, an "amateur."
- arethuza 17y agoSo what are you if you are doing research and you aren't paid to do it? I've been in that situation where I had a "day" job (running a software company) and doing a PhD on the side? I was certainly part of the academic community but I wasn't a paid "professional" researcher.
- scott_s 17y agoYou are by no means an amateur researcher in that case. In this context, "professional" does not mean "paid to do it." It means vetted or accredited in some way. PhD students are in the process of being vetted, are a part of the system.
- arethuza 17y agoI guess I tend to react to the term "professional" rather strongly because I'm married to a lawyer, have a brother who is a professionally qualified engineer and I know a few medical doctors. To me those are real "professionals" - folks who have jobs where you are personally held liable and if you screw up badly enough they can take your professional qualification away from you and you are out of work as you can't legally do the job without that qualification. In that context there is a very sharp boundary between "professional" and not - for the rest of us the boundary is rather fuzzy. I certainly don't regard myself as a professional simply because I am paid to do something or that I make my living out of it or even, unlikely as it may seem, occasionally show some competence ;-)