3 ms·
Let's not pretend that this is a new issue for American society. We have almost 250 years of making these sorts of decisions. For example, we know that bad guy
by snowwrestler 11y ago
Let's not pretend that this is a new issue for American society. We have almost 250 years of making these sorts of decisions.
For example, we know that bad guys use guns to commit crimes, yet we're very very reluctant to ban guns. Bad guys use cars, but we don't require cars to come with remote kill switches.
Bad guys use encryption. Shall we therefore ban it? Or destroy its effectiveness? Do any good guys use encryption? And should we take those uses in to consideration as we think about public policy?
The President of the U.S. uses an iPad. Millions of federal employees, including FBI agents, use iPhones. Let's think about the implications of punching a hole in the security of those devices.
It's very easy to make decisions when one ignores the broader context and consequences. That doesn't mean it's the right way to make decisions.
- grecy 11y ago(To play devils advocate, coming from the perspective of my retired LEO friend) legal warrants can we written to seize guns which can then be tested and information extracted from them. Legal warrants can be written to search and seize cars, so they can be searched and extensively examined to extract information/evidence from them. The argument goes that right now, warrants can be written to gain access to basically everything a criminal has/owns/has been in contact with so that it can all be gobbled up and analyzed. People supporting the government in this believe the same is true for digital data - they don't care that it's on a phone or laptop or "online", they just think a warrant should let the government access it. If Apple can do it, then they must. (Note I don't personally agree with that, but I understand it)
- zeveb 11y ago> If Apple can do it, then they must. Which is why they ought to ensure that they cannot do it. And it's why we should resist any law mandating that they be forced to include a pre-emptive backdoor.
- hahainternet 11y ago> Bad guys use cars, but we don't require cars to come with remote kill switches. Nobody is asking for a remote kill switch. Searching a car is a common task, searching a phone should be the same. > Let's think about the implications of punching a hole in the security of those devices. Nobody is talking about uploading new software to every device. This is wildly misleading.