5 ms·
I was surprised to learn that iOS 4 - 8 permits updating the firmware without first entering the PIN. Device Firmware Update mode https://www.theiphonewiki.com
by specialist 11y ago
I was surprised to learn that iOS 4 - 8 permits updating the firmware without first entering the PIN.
Device Firmware Update mode
https://www.theiphonewiki.com/wiki/DFU_Mode https://www.theiphonewiki.com/wiki/DFU_Mode
This technical factoid is relevant to the current discussion. I did not understand how creating a custom firmware was useful.
To further ground the discussion, I found this informative:
Legal Process Guidelines U.S. Law Enforcement
https://ssl.apple.com/privacy/docs/legal-process-guidelines-us.pdf https://ssl.apple.com/privacy/docs/legal-process-guidelines-...
Whereas before I was firmly against Apple helping to crack the San Bernadino iPhone, I'm now merely mostly against.
I don't understand how this action can help FBI. What additional, unique information could possibly be on this phone that they couldn't discover by alternate means?
I don't understand how an error by FBI obligates Apple to clean up their mess.
My understanding is that iOS 9 changed things so that this kind of forensics backdoor is no longer possible, mooting this discussion.
FBI should take their lumps and learn from their mistakes.
- ascagnel_ 11y ago> My understanding is that iOS 9 changed things so that this kind of forensics backdoor is no longer possible, mooting this discussion. The question Apple would like to avoid is if, in the future, creating such a backdoor-resistant OS will be illegal. iOS 9.2.1 (the latest pre-ruling release) is legal; however, any future releases of the OS with this capability may be considered a circumvention of or non-compliance with the ruling.
- specialist 11y agoAha. I just reread the letter. I would like them to use your direct language. The use of encryption is a human right (to privacy). I utterly oppose any measure to curtail my right to privacy. Arguing about the technical whatnots, and who did what when, as I've done here, is a trap, to better obscure the fundamentals. And I fell for it. So thank you. I know it feels like restating obvious. But I needed to be reminded what's at stake here.