6 ms·
Intuit's PolOps are also continuously trying to keep the US Tax system complex, so they have a reason to exist that isn't the case in other countries: http://w
by zdw 11y ago
Intuit's PolOps are also continuously trying to keep the US Tax system complex, so they have a reason to exist that isn't the case in other countries:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/24/business/24digi.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/24/business/24digi.html?_r=0
http://techcrunch.com/2013/03/27/turbotax-maker-funnels-millions-to-lobby-against-easier-tax-returns/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/03/27/turbotax-maker-funnels-mill...
If you want something evil to disrupt, disrupt this.
- username223 11y agoYep -- this is some pretty evil rent-seeking. Unfortunately, disrupting it (i.e. automatic filing) requires political action rather than tech. For people with a single wage/salary job, the IRS already has a good idea what they owe thanks to their employers' reporting. IRS could simply mail them "we think $X is what you made, and $Y is what you owe," and they could either say "okay" if they agree, or fill out the forms otherwise.
- cballard 11y agoIt seems that we should just require any company providing taxable things to common people (e.g. employers and banks) to do all of the work. Then the IRS can just figure it all out from that, you have a few checkboxes for if you have dependents, and it does all of the math for you. That way we have a smaller set of organizations doing the work once instead of every taxpayer doing it independently.
- coldpie 11y agoBut think of the cost such regulation would cause upon our poor, under-served businesses! There's no way they could survive under such obligations! Won't somebody think of the businesses?!? And don't forget to conveniently ignore the time cost of each individual taxpayer spending several hours every year doing their taxes (not to mention evaluating dozens of healthcare options...) or paying some business to do their taxes instead.
- maxerickson 11y agoWhat work do you mean? There are already extensive reporting requirements for pretty much any entity involved in a situation where someone might make income. I think pretty much any tax document an individual receives has also been provided to the IRS. (For instance, stock brokers must now track lots for their customers, employers withhold payroll taxes and report income, etc)
- masklinn 11y agoPretty much how it works in most of europe. Not even mailed, during the filing period log into the tax authority's site, check that the pre-filled declaration looks OK and validate.
- willis77 11y agoSounds glorious. In the U.S., figuring out taxes is like: Take line 39b, multiply it by your age as determined by worksheet 6689. If you are between 41 and 43 years of age, enter '0'. If you were not subject to the Railroad Act of 1938's exempt dependent pension clause (this is not common), add 13 to this number in hexadecimal, else, subtract 2 and multiply by 1.388688. If you did not have healthcare for more than 14 minutes during the prior year and line 17 is 4 or greater and you live in a zone designated as "clown free" by your local municipality, draw a unicode snowman on this line and prove Fermat's theorem in the margins of Schedule Q...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWe can change this if we want. We just need to collaborate and apply pressure on legislators. 1. Propose legislation to allow the IRS to perform the work directly third parties are currently performing 2. Have it sponsored (look through opensecrets.org, find legislators who aren't taking money from intuit) 3. If you don't vote for it, we work to replace your with a competitor in your next election cycle
- algorithmsRcool 11y agoIs this really the case? Can't most people can just file with a 1040(A or EZ) and be done pretty quickly. I was under the impression that you only have to break out the crazy worksheets or software if you want to get fancy with your deductions or take advantage of tax credits. You can save alot of money this way, but really it's the deductions that are the complication (and the audit risk...) but how can you simplify the deduction process, you have to get specific by the very nature of the task.
- johnward 11y ago
- shmerl 11y agoYeah, a very fishy company. Stay away: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TurboTax#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TurboTax#Controversies
- bicknergseng 11y agoHas anyone tried to make an open source version? Any 18f or USDS folks around who want to save us from Intuit and H&R Block?
- loeg 11y agoYes. The problem is the damn tax code changes every year (see: Intuit's lobbying) and you need to pay for an army of lawyers for when you get it wrong.
- tosseraccount 11y agoInuit is not alone. Accountants and tax lawyers want it kept changing and complex, too.
- serge2k 11y agoIsn't it more like every day?
- cptskippy 11y agoThe trouble is that there would have to be a new version every year for the new tax code changes and it would need to be updated in a timely manner. We're talking like Chrome or Firefox level of support for an app most people would use once a year.
- jccalhoun 11y agoThe last couple years I've filled out my tax forms with a couple different online forms and found they gave different results. (Last year I filed my state taxes through one company and federal through another) The fact that programs that exist only to do taxes can't even agree on how much my taxes are shows how broken the USA's tax system is. (and my returns are fairly simply. I can't imagine how different they would be if I had complicated returns)
- curun1r 11y agoIt's an interesting balance that Intuit is trying to strike. They want the tax code complex enough that people don't feel they can do it by themselves but simple enough that they don't feel that they need to hire a CPA. Since every filer is different, there will be some that fall on either end of the spectrum (though they have their free products to address the simple cases), but the goal is to keep as many people in that "comfortable using software" group as possible. What's truly amazing is just how little it costs to buy that influence. IIRC, it's in the $10m-$15m per year range, which is less than half of what they spend on hosting for TurboTax alone. I've had conversations with Brad Smith (CEO) and Scott Cook (Founder) and often considered asking them how they can reconcile their "Integrity Without Compromise" corporate value with these kinds of lobbying activities, but I never had the stones to ask the question. I will say that from my interactions with them, I'm positive that they do have some rationalization in their heads that makes them actually believe that what they're doing isn't evil, I'm just not sure what it is. Disclaimer: Former Intuit employee, though not on TurboTax.
- st3v3r 11y agoBut then wouldn't you be relying on the same thing? The only real way to disrupt it is through government.