4 ms·
I don't know about Wal-Mart (but I'd expect their management structure to be lean in the Sam Walton era), but the DoD in the Vietnam period was where I first he
by hga 17y ago
I don't know about Wal-Mart (but I'd expect their management structure to be lean in the Sam Walton era), but the DoD in the Vietnam period was where I first heard of this principle. And the US Army certainly didn't go a good job of carrying out their mission then (the US Navy hasn't been put to the test since WWII ... and one might say they haven't been doing a bang up job of policing the sea lanes as of late (South China Sea, off the Horn of Africa)).
I don't think most companies are different, at least when it comes to the non-rote stuff. I.e. in a fast food restaurant the people are the bottom are supposed to be following a "book".
With the exception of navies, I don't think that works in warfare (I make this exception since most of the lower people have clear missions like "keep the ship afloat" and "fire this gun"; that doesn't work for infantry, armor or tactical air (might work in part for artillery)).
It most certainly applies for software firms, e.g. the IBM Chief Programmer Team concept has been shown not to work in practice.
- philwelch 17y ago"And the US Army certainly didn't go a good job of carrying out their mission [in Vietnam] (the US Navy hasn't been put to the test since WWII ... and one might say they haven't been doing a bang up job of policing the sea lanes as of late (South China Sea, off the Horn of Africa))" In both cases, the mission was hampered by political leadership. The military was winning the Vietnam War, it was just taking longer than necessary because the White House was micromanaging the war and establishing unrealistic rules and requirements. As for piracy, the Navy has been kept out of the game because it's cheaper to pay ransom than to pay for any significant military operations against pirates. There was a time where we would say "millions for defense but not a penny for tribute", land the Marines in North Africa, and force the pirates to allow safe passage. Nowadays we'd rather pay the tribute--and invading Somalia would be a far more difficult mission.
- hga 17y agoAgreed on "hampered by political leadership", but my studies of the US Army in the period tells me it also was a very large factor in the early to middle part of the mess (About Face by Hackworth would be a good first book to read on this). I could go into many details but this is probably not the forum for that. One big leadership one, though, is apropos: the 6 month tour of duty "ticket punch" for officers. For the Army at large (at least for a long time) it was perceived that Vietnam was a side show to the greater Cold War. However it was also perceived that getting "combat experience" was going to be a necessary part of one's "resume" for higher advancement. So officers would come in for a 6 six month tour ... and I probably don't have to detail how badly that worked out.
- philwelch 17y agoIn any significant engagement you're going to have a long period where you consistently fuck up and have to adjust. A healthy organization actually will adjust, though, and that's more important, because whether you get it right at first has more to do with whether you've been doing substantially the same thing recently, which for the military largely depends upon how warlike the politicians have been lately ;)
- hga 17y agoBingo: the US military or at least the Army has long had the reputation of starting out the greenest and learning the fastest. What struck me the most WRT Vietnam was the learning part horribly broke down, at least in the Army (I actually haven't studied much about the Marines there). One reason blue water navies tend to do better right off the bat in a war is that just doing the blue water navy thing (keeping your ships from colliding and sinking when they're out at sea per the doctrine) requires a minimal level of competence that just isn't required in ground force exercises (assuming you can get the money to do any of any scale). Hmmm, gunnery exercises probably also work better. On the other hand, every major naval force at the beginning of WWII had major flaws with their torpedoes ... and the US Navy was pretty much the worst in dealing with them (Washington refused to listen and the various flaws had to be debugged in Hawaii; by contrast the Germans found and fixed theirs quickly and cashiered two officers responsible for them (the latter from memory)).