3 ms·
> Add to that, that they do not care about copyright and license issues and just ship their ISOs with pre-installed Oracle Java and Adobe Flash packages and sev
by mschuster91 11y ago
> Add to that, that they do not care about copyright and license issues and just ship their ISOs with pre-installed Oracle Java and Adobe Flash packages and several multimedia codec packages which infringe patents and may therefore not be distributed freely at all in countries like the US.
Seriously, with the rotten-ness of the US patent/copyright/political system, it's better for mankind to just say "ok, US users can't get this, but everyone else can".
E.g. many European banks do this for "US persons" - they simply cannot get accounts because the legal risks are just too high.
Edit: It's not just banks. E.g. BMW Group (and likely other huge non-US corps with US subsidiaries) refuse to allow US persons to look at financial statements, again due to regulatory hassle.
- smt88 11y ago> "ok, US users can't get this, but everyone else can" Setting aside for a minute that this isn't possible, it's like saying you won't release your app on iOS because of Apple's walled gardens. Sure, the walls suck, but the users inside are numerous and spend lots of money. Most product creators don't have the option to exclude US users.
- beefsack 11y agoNot everyone is entirely driven by money, I choose not to write software for any of the walled gardens.
- zymhan 11y agoWait, so you avoid walled gardens by...exercising your right to include proprietary plugins in software?
- cowl 11y agoNobody is saying to not release for US (in fact you can choose to use the noCodex version) but Why Should problems in US or anywhere else limit the experience that everyone else can get?
- oxguy3 11y agoTo be quite honest, I wish a lot of app developers _would_ do that, and then maybe Apple would loosen up a bit.
- Narann 11y agoI'm also surprised how often I ear about this "patent" argument while actually "the world except US" don't recognize software patents. It's really a "US only" problem, the rest of the world don't care about this.
- TD-Linux 11y agoMost patent encumbered codecs have patents worldwide, including in most EU countries. Go to the MPEG-LA website and take a look at the patent lists if you're curious.
- brobinson 11y ago>E.g. many European banks do this for "US persons" - they simply cannot get accounts because the legal risks are just too high. It's not legal risks, it's the cost of compliance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance...
- TD-Linux 11y agoThe copyright and patent issues involved with those packages are still valid in other countries though.
- RaleyField 11y ago> Seriously, with the rotten-ness of the US patent/copyright/political system I've gotten this vibe on Reddit, but it seems people seem to be against copyright unless it's Youtube not enforcing it vigorously enough when it comes to small channel owners getting their content stolen. Then suddenly everyone appears to be for copyright laws.