4 ms·
I'll go ahead and say that it sounds extremely sincere and straight-forward, much unlike most official statements I've seen from the FBI. He does suggest that h
by noobermin 11y ago
I'll go ahead and say that it sounds extremely sincere and straight-forward, much unlike most official statements I've seen from the FBI. He does suggest that his view is right, but he does the right thing, as apple did, in supporting a public discourse about the so-called balance between privacy and safety.
I know many people seem to gravitate to the extremes on every issue, but both Cook and Comey are right in saying that we as a nation need to question our fundamental assumptions in our thinking and think through what the would be the best balance between the two, if there be any. As Comey says, and I personally agree with this, the "balance" shouldn't be decided "by corporations that sell stuff for a living" or by "the FBI which investigates for a living,"...or in general, the government. We shouldn't be grass in a fight between two elephants. The American people need to decide how much involvement both government and large multinational corporations have in their lives. That's what this all comes down to, after all.
- thetruthseeker1 11y agoSounds extremely straight forward and sincere(many bad decisions are also taken with utmost sincerity) but I would think it would be a bad idea to provide FBI this ability. For one, it is forever weakening the security and privacy of your iphone. Bad guys who want to evade the policy officers will do it anyway with encryption systems/software available from any of the non US territories. Considering that FBI can get significant meta data from telecom providers(who called whom etc), I think this requirement that FBI has gives little gain in security as the upside and comes with a significant downside[ huge loss in privacy].
- ikeboy 11y agohttp://bloombergview.com/articles/2016-02-17/the-apple-fight-isn-t-about-encryption http://bloombergview.com/articles/2016-02-17/the-apple-fight... argues and I agree that the loss of freedom is precisely when you can't install your own software onto a phone in your possession.
- 05 11y agoThe article author is incompetent, it's all about private keys, not 'source code'. Neither Android OEMs nor Apple allows the user to set their own root cert.
- ikeboy 11y ago>Neither Android OEMs nor Apple allows the user to set their own root cert. Where does the article imply it does? It states correctly that the FBI would have easily hacked it had it been an android. edit: I'm assuming you're going from this line: >Although user content is encrypted on Android devices, too, Android is open-source software. Theoretically, the government can produce its own version of the system that would make it possible to hack the encryption. This is poorly worded, as is the line about how all encryption can be hacked, but he gets the point about how Android would have been vulnerable. I think some of that can be chalked down to writing for the public and not a technical audience.
- allworknoplay 11y agoSecurity vs privacy is a false dichotomy here. Backdoors can help law enforcement achieve some goals but weaken overall security. The debate is security vs security, and framing it any other way reflects either willful deceit or ignorance.
- FreedomToCreate 11y agoEncryption could also help obstruct justice and let criminals get away with things. Most people won't understand till it impacts them personally but imagine if you are robbed of all your money and the answer of who did it lies in a computer you are able to get your hand on. Wouldn't you love it if the police had a backdoor now. You are wrong in framing the debate as security vs security. Its like everything else when it comes to liberty and protection. The question is how much liberty are we willing to give up for protection. We can't let a corporation or the government anchor our opinions on the left or right.
- autoreleasepool 11y agoCan you cite a case where encryption has obstructed justice or prevented a crime from being solved?
- FreedomToCreate 11y agoYes, http://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/12/opinion/apple-google-when-phone-encryption-blocks-justice.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/12/opinion/apple-google-when-... Also I believe even without the citation that the notion that criminals can use encryption to protect themselves is pretty obvious.
- autoreleasepool 11y agoEven more obvious is the notion that innocent civilians use encryption to protect themselves from mass survelence and needless data collection. Is the end goal no longer total information awareness? [0] Side note: that was a rather scathing and slanted article you cited. It would have been nice to see the simple facts of the case presented in a neutral light. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_Information_Awareness https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_Information_Awareness