3 ms·
Just to be clear: 1. Apple does not market their devices as secure against nation state attackers. 2. You have not detailed any alternative that is.
by zepto 11y ago
Just to be clear:
1. Apple does not market their devices as secure against nation state attackers.
2. You have not detailed any alternative that is.
- mindslight 11y ago> Apple does not market their devices as secure against nation state attackers. Then what exactly is this court case for? > You have not detailed any alternative that is As I had just said, Linux's LUKS/dmcrypt. The authors simply do not have the power to unlock other peoples' volumes. Some other properties are traded off, but since you are unwilling to discuss system models ("completely hypothetical"), then I don't see the point of detailing the landscape. A system can have a vulnerability without needing a nearly-identical system without the vulnerability for comparison.
- zepto 11y agoLUKS/dmcrypt is a small component that cannot provide anywhere near the necessary features to substitute for the iOS security system. You don't it to be nearly identical, but if it can't do the job, then it is an invalid comparison.
- mindslight 11y ago> If you want to persist in that assertion, you should easily be able to point to the marketing you are refering to This case right here! We've got, by most anybody's standards, a legitimate search warrant. There's no judicial overreach with regards to scope; process is the only thing they're arguing in the legal realm. The FBI could adjust their request for technical documentation on the KDF, create their own hardware, and the forced creation aspect would disappear. The only reason Apple didn't quietly unlock the phone was because the FBI publicized the request (against Apple's wishes), and Apple wanted to avoid the inevitable press field day undermining their reality distortion field of "privacy". > LUKS/dmcrypt is a small component that cannot provide anywhere near the necessary features to substitute for the iOS security system. LOL. And yet a default Debian install would be locked for eternity (barring implementation flaws, which are not under discussion here for either system). You can't have it both ways - arguing the properties provided by each system differ, while simultaneously refusing to discuss security models. You're attempting to narrow the domain to a single point, so that no objective comparisons can be made. The sheer ridiculousness of this statement leads me to believe I'm talking to an Apple partisan rather than someone who earnestly analyzes security, so I don't see the point of continuing this discussion.
- zepto 11y agoOnce again, you call Tim Cook a liar. A default Debian install is nowhere near to being able to replace iOS as a practical smartphone OS for 1 billion users. This is an indisputable fact. What is ridiculous is that you seem to be claiming otherwise. We are talking about the real world where objective comparisons can very much be made. I'm trying to discus real software - not fantasy extrapolations. For the record, if an open, secure, and practical alternative existed I'd much prefer it to what Apple has produced, and I have been hoping for such a solution since the iphone was introduced. It seems a lot more like you're the one with an agenda to push.