2 ms·
Accepting your first paragraph as true, even though it is debatable - nobody has even done that with the kind of system you are proposing. Until they do, you a
by zepto 11y ago
Accepting your first paragraph as true, even though it is debatable - nobody has even done that with the kind of system you are proposing. Until they do, you are arguing favor of an imaginary system over a real one. It should be obvious that this is not an approach to security.
- mindslight 11y agoYou had asked what the current situation has to do with open/closed, and I detailed an open alternative. You're now arguing against my explanation as if it affects the main point. I didn't need to describe a better way in order to analyze the failings of Apple's system. If you aren't interested in an example of how open trusted hardware could function, then just ignore it and judge the system on its own merit. The fundamental flaw remains that Apple utilizes closed-design trusted hardware based on a manufacturer backdoor. This type of system is insecure against the manufacturer (and by extension USG), and marketing it as secure against such is willfully negligent.
- zepto 11y agoAs I said they have never marketed anything in the way that you claim. If you want to persist in that assertion, you should easily be able to point to the marketing you are refering to.