4 ms·
Amateurs are a useful check on the system because they will never submit a grant proposal to the committee chaired by the co-investigator of the paper they're r
by patio11 17y ago
Amateurs are a useful check on the system because they will never submit a grant proposal to the committee chaired by the co-investigator of the paper they're reviewing, and hence can make aggressive, confrontational demands of his code like running it.
- JoachimSchipper 17y agoWhich is why almost every scientific publication does not tell the peer reviewers who the author is, and vice versa.
- jgrahamc 17y agoMy experience with reviewing papers was that it was pretty easy to figure out who the author was because each field contains a limited number of specialists. And looking at the references on a paper enables you to narrow it down. It's a bit like the situation with date of birth and CVs: you can figure out how old someone is, if you want to know that, by looking at their degree year.
- arethuza 17y agoGiven the hyper specialisation of most academic research, circle of people involved in an area can be pretty small. You probably don't even need to read the paper - just to know what kind of approach to what problem they are taking and you can make a good guess of the people/team involved.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoIn my experience (math, physics, CS), most journals are only single blind. The referee is anonymous, the author is not. Additionally, referees can sometimes give themselves away. The authors also fail to cite [Irrelevant Paper, Irrelevant Paper 2, Peripherally related paper 3]. These works should be cited and compared to the work being reviewed. "Irrelevant Paper", John Smith. Journal of Trivialities, 1995. "Irrelevant Paper 2", by John Smith and Steve Jones. Journal of followups to irrelevant papers, 1998. "Peripherally related paper 3", by John Smith and Phil Johnson. Journal of Blah Blah, 2002.
- scott_s 17y agoA minority of CS conferences are double-blind - I've only submitted to one that was. But it's difficult to maintain true author-blindness. If your work builds on previous work at all, it's difficult to maintain that. Further, I once reviewed a paper that was double-blind, and before I made it through the abstract I knew immediately where the paper came from. (Not the specific authors, but I knew it had to be from a particular company.)