3 ms·
> Raising taxes so money can be given to people who clearly need it isn't "big government" in any meaningful sense Huh, I know a lot of people who would disagr
by mike_hearn 11y ago
> Raising taxes so money can be given to people who clearly need it isn't "big government" in any meaningful sense
Huh, I know a lot of people who would disagree with you on that one - big time.
All civilised countries need a welfare state. But it's hard to argue that this is not "big government" because unless you have a basic income (which nowhere does), all welfare systems require enormous bureaucracies to manage the flow of money, find and fight fraudulent claims, try to get people who are on welfare back off it again, follow up individual cases, gather statistics on the systems performance and so on. They need this because "people who clearly need it" is an unusably vague standard.
In practice, the standard figures I've seen for overheads of welfare spending are about 5-20%. According to this article, the USA Medicaid program has overheads of about 5% and food stamps is closer to 17%:
http://mediamatters.org/research/2005/09/21/limbaugh-dramatically-overstated-administrative/133859 http://mediamatters.org/research/2005/09/21/limbaugh-dramati...
> This doesn't contribute at all to the problems of unaccountable and unchecked power.
The welfare state is pretty much the embodiment of unaccountable and unchecked power! The only time you can ever hold it to account is during elections and then it's competing with many other issues. The rest of the time it's run by unelected and often rather opaque bureaucracies!
Look, I am not arguing that welfare is bad. All countries need a safety net (although I note that most welfare spending, in the UK at least, is actually on pensions and not the safety net).
But just because we may like having such a thing doesn't mean we should be blind to its costs.
Final comment:
> When underfunded government institutions get replaced with unaccountable for-profit organizations the citizens are far worse off.
The vast majority of organisations I deal with in my daily life are for-profit organisations held to account through market power. Most things in my life (food, home, water, energy, heat, furniture, internet, etc) are provided by such organisations. There have been countries that tried it the other way around - all such things were provided by the state. That was called communism and it collapsed.