4 ms·
While these were all tragic, they are hardly representative. Do you know how when you ride a bicycle and look off to one side, you tend to steer towards that s
by pmarreck 11y ago
While these were all tragic, they are hardly representative.
Do you know how when you ride a bicycle and look off to one side, you tend to steer towards that side, involuntarily?
Stop being obsessed with oppression, depression and suicide. Not to downplay them, but you have free will (oh, debatable, sure, but it's better for happiness to just believe you do) and can act, and can steer your consciousness towards more positive points on the horizon.
- majewsky 11y ago> Stop being obsessed with [...] depression. So you're one of the persons who would suggest to clinically depressed people to "just smile again" as if that would magically solve all their problems and mental disorders? The point is that even if such people are a minority, we should treat them with the appropriate discretion and be sensitive to their psychological needs.
- moonchrome 11y ago>So you're one of the persons who would suggest to clinically depressed people to "just smile again" as if that would magically solve all their problems and mental disorders? It sounds more like "things aren't panning out the way they were supposed to" in his head and now he's mad about it and he's trying to find ways to make it a systemic issue rather than one of his own goals/achievements/motivation.
- FLUX-YOU 11y ago>The point is that even if such people are a minority, we should treat them with the appropriate discretion and be sensitive to their psychological needs. Which should not involve radically changing the "commercial software shop" because some individuals do not do well in that environment (or worse, blaming it systemic abuse) as the article says. The only role that businesses should be doing here is keeping the issues confidential and allowing them to get the help that they need.
- pmarreck 11y ago> who would suggest to clinically depressed people to "just smile again" as if that would magically solve all their problems and mental disorders? No. I'm not saying that at all, and tried to point that out. But something like 75% of this article is focusing squarely on unhappiness. That's all I'm saying. If all you do is write about unhappiness and end up suiciding, is it really that surprising? Your body is what you consume physically; your mind is what you consume media-wise. If all you do is read Sylvia Plath poetry all day, and then write poetry inspired by Sylvia Plath, then you may in fact end up just like she did. What tipped me off is that he even said he wanted to suicide dozens of times. Which on the one hand, is kind of "TMI" for an article like this, and on the other hand... so why are you reading about other suicides? That is what I'm saying. That, and most of the people cited already had diagnosable mental difficulties, which means he is openly confusing the apparent proximal cause between "oppressed IT person" and "is emotionally-challenged already" One night not too long ago, I couldn't sleep, and for whatever reason I decided to watch 9/11 videos on YouTube. Guess what happened? I fell asleep and had nightmares, and for the next day(s) I was depressed as hell. I surely didn't function as well as I could and, dare I say it, I am sure I brought less goodness into the world as a result. All because I focused on watching 9/11 videos and listening to final phone calls and watching people fall to their deaths from great heights, one night. It's worldview distortion, basically. Yes, bad things happen and sometimes, bosses are jerks. Yes, some people have emotional difficulties (some of which should be treated clinically). Yes, IT careers seem to draw in a bumper-crop of sensitive folks (it's the curse of high intelligence, really). From this, you cannot draw the conclusion that there is a systematic problem going on. Disclaimer: I'm diagnosed ADD, AND sleep apnea, and (sometimes) take meds for it (on bad days when I really need to function), so I'm not the kind of person who wouldn't understand that some things just need treatment.
- wcummings 11y agoYou don't just "stop" having intrusive thoughts, that's why they're called intrusive.
- solipsism 11y agoI agree with your first sentence. Alan Turing's death especially can't be attributed to abuse in the software industry. The rest of your comment is not only condescending, it is baseless. Your premise that the author should think happy thoughts and he will be okay if not as helpful as you may think. The author may or may not suffer from a depression/mood disorder, or even many other more serious conditions. You don't know him. Instead consider telling people that they should talk to a therapist about their problems. You know, an expert.
- pmarreck 11y agoI can no longer edit what I wrote, so I followed up in the thread trying to clarify my position.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoOh, I totally agree with you. Evidence is on your side as well. My Christian buddies trying to get people to live more righteously have a nice saying for it: Garbage In, Garbage Out. I gave them a pun Goodness In, Goodness Out for end result. Idea being you have to feed your brain the kinds of things it can build on to achieve the result you want. Anyway, the effect has its basis in intuition: our unconscious or semi-consciuos mind. Intuition runs most of our thoughts, feelings, and reactions based on prior experiences and decisions. A researcher once connected this to depression when he noticed that animals put into helpless situations learned to act helpless even when the situation changed. He experimented with a sort of mental reprogramming for humans based on speculation that it was in our head in some percentage of cases. That led to cognitive therapy which cured quite a few people of depression. Its methods were quite simple: record your reactions to negative situations; identify whether you overstate the severity or pervasiveness of it; create a neutral or positive way to reframe that which isn't bullshit; take time to actually say and believe that; keep that up. Over significant period of time, habit takes over where you start coming up with less negative stuff or countering it in your head without thinking. Random other examples. The optimism studies support that people similarly highlighting the good and margalizing the bad live longer, feel better, succeed more, and so on. They do something similar to cognitive therapy although positivity comes before accuracy. Proponents of meditation find that clearing all those thoughts out of their head for small amounts of time helps their mental state across the board. Also note that it's initially a painful process that takes work to do. Monks used to fight evil and negative thoughts by meditating on love and beautiful aspects of life. Stress management shows us even primitive tricks like smacking a wall saying "Stop!" can interrupt that thinking with a different focus area as a follow-up. The anecdotes, behavioral science, and neuroscience all corroborate each other supporting the GIGO concept. Mental illness has a variety of effects on this but I've seen it help many with it. Techniques, effect, and length of effect varies considerably but it's rarely a "nothing will help" situation. The author could be applying such things but is hyperfocused on suicide, despair, negative thoughts, all the ways he will fail... Garbage In, Garbage Out. What he didn't write is about all that didn't commit suicide, were kind of OK, were happy once they left the building, or rare few that didn't let others affect internal happiness. He didn't point out that some people have convinced management to tackle technical debt or do preventative work by putting it in terms they understand. We see a number in HN posts each month. He didn't show examples of software shops doing it better along with their methods in his recommendations to change structural problems he wrote on in prior essay. Didn't do that because he probably never looked for such positive counterpoints in the first place. Even the suicides are a questionable list with Aaron and Murdock being great examples of people tied to thinking & behaviors that will only screw them up. So many others fought for utilitarianism and ideals with a cut-off point that left them otherwise happy with their lives and away from B&E's. So, if anything, this article proves nothing about the effect of software industry on developers or suicide. Instead, it tells us a lot about how one person thinks. It also confirms that focusing only on negative aspects of life will lead to depression and possibly suicide. It implies people should do the opposite. Additionally, they might consider putting a lot of effort into finding and moving into a better work environment.