5 ms·
> none of the moral compass of a human I find this notion laughable, that a "moral compass" prevents individuals from attempting to lower their tax burden as m
by modeless 11y ago
> none of the moral compass of a human
I find this notion laughable, that a "moral compass" prevents individuals from attempting to lower their tax burden as much as corporations. Individuals are no different than corporations in the desire to avoid paying taxes. The difference is that the amounts are smaller, so they can't afford as many lawyers, and the tax laws are less complex, so generally fewer loopholes are available.
If it was advantageous for individuals to set up European subsidiaries for tax purposes, I guarantee everyone would be doing it, "moral compass" be damned.
- ownagefool 11y agoThe problem is if your moral compass does prevent you from taking advantage of tax breaks, you're suddenly disadvantaged against those who do thus leading to pretty much any pragmatist to reconsider. Given game theory logic, I'll pretty much abuse any loopholes I think I can, but that doesn't mean I don't think we should change the rules of the game.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoAnd that's why we can't have nice things. Yes, if you refrain from defecting, you lose to others. That's why it's in everyone's best interest to severly punish anyone who games the system. That's why society developed customs and laws against theft and murder. The "if it's legal, it's ok, morality be damned" attitude is antisocial - it's a danger to civilized world. Therefore everyone who wants to follow their moral code or at least likes civilization should not only refrain from abusing the rules, but actively shun people who game them. Cooperation is a superior solution, but a one that is unstable by itself and needs maintenance (i.e. enforcing the rules and setting up the expectation that defectors will be penalized).
- csallen 11y agoPeople already do follow their own moral codes. However, morality is subjective. What's "right" to you isn't necessarily "right" to someone else. Additionally, it's part of human nature to act in our own self-interest. Call it antisocial if you want, but it's part of us. We're people, not ants. Trying to fight against that desire is a losing battle. Instead, the focus should be entirely on the system itself to create such tremendous disincentives for crime/cheating/etc that it's in our self interest to follow the law (e.g. the laws against theft and murder that you pointed out).
- bko 11y agoA corporation is under a lot more societal pressure than individuals in regards to following norms and ethics. Most corporations (including Google) only exists because people choose to do business with them and they are happy with their product and price. Google does plenty of charitable ventures that don't add any value for this reason and it makes sense. A corporations bottom line is hurt when people have negative views of their company, product or practices. Individuals don't really have this amount of pressure. An individual can be immoral but legal and likely not lose their income. If people have a negative view of a corporation and choose not to purchase their product or use their service, the corporation suffers and therefore has an incentive to behave ethically. The reason that Google and other companies can get away with these practices is that most people don't care enough to not use their product. They still find their value proposition attractive. The gains from the unethical behavior is less than the lost revenue from those that do care. Personally, I am not concerned about their minimizing taxes as I believe that the government isn't a great steward of the taxes they collect and the extra revenue brought it would not have a positive effect.
- Shorel 11y ago> That's why it's in everyone's best interest to severly punish anyone who games the system. That's in the judicial system best interest. A better society would be more impervious to being gamed.
- rmc 11y ago> If it was advantageous for individuals to set up European subsidiaries for tax purposes, I guarantee everyone would be doing it, "moral compass" be damned. To a certain degree that already happens. U2 are often disliked in Ireland because they have a Dutch tax set up, so they hardly pay any taxes in Ireland. People even sneak "Pay your taxes" ballons into concerts, like this one at Gastonbury ( http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2011/jun/28/glastonbury-u2-tax-protest http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2011/jun/28/glaston... )
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThe sensible answer to this issue is tax reform, to make sure the real world use of tax laws matches more closely to the intended consequences of the tax laws. However, in the meantime, we can still send a clear message that the behaviour being engaged in is not desired. If words alone will not build enough momentum for change, then people could resort to civil disobedience. For example, Google is dependent on its advertising business, it would be trivial to "legally" damage this (for example, running bots that clicked on Google ads but did not purchase anything, inflating the cost of running ads without increasing revenue for those running them. Similar schemes would work for Facebook and others). I'd hope it didn't come to that, but if companies can act without a moral compass, I don't see why the general population has to act any better.
- tim333 11y agoI think you're sending the clear message to the wrong party. It's the politicians you should be lobbying to tax companies on their real global profits, ignoring offshore shenanigans. I'm sure some corporate lobbyists lobby the opposite so we the people need to counter that.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoI don't think so. The important point is to get it discussed in the media. It's the media which acts as the main arbiter for public discourse. Politicians are more or less free to act as they wish so long as the media does not amplify the voice of dissenters. Actions which bring the voice of the people into the mainstream media are of use in bringing about change. Hopefully this public discourse can happen through debate alone, but if a legal but questionable method like a botnet that targets corporate greed is required to get the debate going (and/or provide impetus for change), then so be it.
- PavlovsCat 11y ago> I find this notion laughable, that a "moral compass" prevents individuals from attempting to lower their tax burden as much as corporations. Correct, I'd argue a functioning moral compass would keep a person from seeing it as a "burden" to begin with. Paying for what I take out and for the less fortunate (until it's my turn to be struck by misfortune) is not a burden, just like waiting in a queue until it's my turn is not an inconvenience. Being aware of the randomness of my own birth and having empathy doesn't require a moral compass, it requires intelligence; it leads to having a moral compass. That you can find that "laughable" you owe to the fact that you were born and cared for as a baby, creating a lot of costs and work for a lot of people, none of which with anything but their moral compass humming gently as a compensation.
- mike_hearn 11y agoIf all you care about is paying in so you can take out, and to help cover unlucky people until it's your rainy day, you don't need any taxes at all, just insurance. In practice taxes are used for all sorts of things which you may or may not agree with (e.g. foreign wars), and other things that you may agree with but maybe don't believe tax and government is the most efficient way to provide it. The blasé assumption that tax == moral is just another form of the left wing assumption that people working for the state have a slight moral superiority over people working in the private sector (and who are therefore tainted by the desire for profit). For some things, there aren't really any better options than paying taxes. Military spending comes to mind. For others, it's sort of an open question (roads and healthcare are cases where countries frequently strike different balances). For yet others, tax is obviously the wrong solution. Nobody these days thinks governments should be in the steel or coal businesses, except China. Unfortunately the nature of tax is that it's rather hard to express your views about it outside of general elections.
- PavlovsCat 11y ago> In practice taxes are used for all sorts of things which you may or may not agree with (e.g. foreign wars), and other things that you may agree with but maybe don't believe tax and government is the most efficient way to provide it. So? You can't evade taxes for A but not B -- if you evade taxes, you are actually more likely to hit, say, orphans, than, say, big business or war profiteers. I can't respond to "may". If you think there is a better way, humor me, though even then I don't see how one should be allowed to "have the cake and eat it", namely profit from the infrastructure upheld in no small part with taxes, but then not pay taxes because there are better ways. Then make business and be a citizen where it's done a better way, or try to change it where you are. And yes, I'm aware that taxes get spent on all sorts of crappy things, that doesn't invalidate the general idea or the social contract, and just because I think "trying to minimize taxes whenever possible by all means" is always immoral, doesn't mean I think all taxes are moral in all instances. > The blasé assumption that tax == moral is just another form of the left wing assumption that people working for the state have a slight moral superiority over people working in the private sector Except I don't have that assumption, so it can't possibly be a form of that. That simply doesn't parse. Though we could discuss the meaning of "profit". Someone who voluntarily reads stories to children with cancer does profit from that, too, and furthermore they are also considering the profit others have from that. So it's still a "desire for profit". Hey, even Jesus asked "what does it profit a man..", profit in itself apparently not the issue, but rather what profit, and at what costs to whom or at what point down the road. Profit, in my books, isn't just measured in the amount of money or land something nets, but in everything it involved to get there.
- danmaz74 11y ago> I guarantee everyone would be doing it I guarantee you that you can't guarantee anything about what I and hundreds of millions of other people would or wouldn't be doing.
- moultano 11y agoConsider the Roth IRA backdoor whereby people who have too much income to directly start a roth can start one by converting a traditional IRA. This is directly in conflict with the intent of the law but is now a standard bit of financial advice.
- transfer24 11y agoRead up on the Step Transaction Doctrine to better understand the legality of the Roth IRA backdoor. Or talk to an actual tax lawyer.