4 ms·
Of course they are rationally choosing that. But they are irrationally not paying their debt back to the same society that made it possible for them to build th
by ThomPete 11y ago
Of course they are rationally choosing that. But they are irrationally not paying their debt back to the same society that made it possible for them to build the business to begin with.
This is not a company who came out of nothing and created the TCP/IP protocols, the Internet, WWW, the billions of pages and information out there.
It's a company who is building on top of something society invested in. And is now trying to avoid paying that back to same said society.
Legally they have no obligations but morally from a company who used to claim "don't be evil" they do.
- fixermark 11y agoGiven that the government they owe those taxes to has consistently minimized funding on infrastructure, has yet to build a national broadband policy that is competitive with the world, and consistently underfunds the NSF year over year while continuing to approve the NSA's black-box budget, perhaps the optimal approach for "Don't be evil" is to do everything within the law to keep their cash in-house, where it can be put to better use?
- ThomPete 11y agoBetter use for who? Right now Google is one of the leading companies in making work obsolete leaving a growing number of people without any chance of participating in the society because digitalization and automation two areas google is one of the key drivers of taking a lot of jobs out of the market. So not only didn't Google create their company in isolation from society but on top of what society established they are also transforming how society works affecting a lot of people negatively. This is not true with all companies but it's certainly true for Google.
- Nutmog 11y agoUsing your argument, internet companies in every country are morally obligated to pay tax to the US government, at least if they claim not to do evil. Do you also agree that every company making cars should pay tax to the German government because Germany started the car industry?
- ThomPete 11y agoNo because the US government didn't invest in the infrastructure in each country. The countries themselves did. No one is saying the obligation is one to one. But the argument that no matter what its always ok for a company to avoid paying taxes as if they created everything completely isolated from government is weak and have always been.