5 ms·
> Google pretending that sales are made in Ireland (and not by the revenue-targeted local salesperson selling local ads to local eyeballs) in order to enable th
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> Google pretending that sales are made in Ireland (and not by the revenue-targeted local salesperson selling local ads to local eyeballs) in order to enable them to deduct fictitious license fees owed to a subsidiary in Bermuda is not even in the same ballpark.
The whole problem is that it isn't a tax on local sales. It isn't a tax on property or labor or consumption. It's a tax on income.
But income is revenue minus expenses. So the company in the US pays developers to make software which costs $99 and the company in Ireland pays $100 for the software. Then the company in Germany sells $1100 worth of advertising and pays $1099 to license the software from the company in Ireland. Which means the company in the US made $1, the company in Germany made $1 and the company in Ireland made $999.
The allocation of the income between the different subsidiaries is almost completely arbitrary so companies arrange to do it in the way that minimizes their taxes. If you don't want them to do this, tax something other than income.
- joering2 11y ago> Which means the company in the US made $1, the company in Germany made $1 and the company in Ireland made $999. Any reasonable judge in their sound mind would find it to be a tax avoidance, because it is! I'm very certain and can put my $100 on it, that US courts know thousands of cases where same scheme has been put in works and people in charge put behind bars. But not Google...
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoTax evasion is the thing where Al Capone makes a lot of money without reporting it to the IRS and goes to jail. Tax avoidance is the thing where Ford builds a plant in Chihuahua instead of Detroit in part because Mexico has lower taxes. There is an obvious PR nightmare when the entity that makes all the profit is in a jurisdiction where they have hardly any operations, but seizing that as an opportunity to lambaste them in public does nothing to solve the actual problem. The underlying problem is this: When Google buys something from Google, how do you determine when the seller should act like a monopoly or the buyer should act like a monopsony? If you can't answer that question in a way that can't be gamed then you can't in practice tax international corporate profit.
- fleitz 11y agoExactly Google would be happy to ship the jobs overseas if they needed 'substantial' operations to take advantage of the tax code. Since workers pay most of the tax it's a double FU to the jurisdiction with high taxes
- baddox 11y agoOf course it's tax avoidance. Tax avoidance is by definition perfectly legal, so no judge would be in a position to accuse a company of it.
- ptaipale 11y agoAnd there are very many kinds of tax avoidance. Apocryphically: at the time when Sweden's income taxes were on their most absurd levels [0], medical doctors would reduce their working hours because their marginal tax rate was well above 50 % and they got little in return for extra hours. This was clearly tax avoidance, or course. Someone then noticed this and made a proposal to tackle it with a tax called "tax on income avoided by refusal to work". That law didn't pass even in Sweden in 1970's. But clearly it was tax avoidance which thus was allowed to run rampant. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pomperipossa_in_Monismania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pomperipossa_in_Monismania
- refurb 11y agoI would imagine that sort of thing falls under "transfer pricing" of which there are plenty of laws and regulations already. If you have a company in the US, but parts are made in China, you can't have the US company pay $99 to their plant in China and claim only $1 in profit in the US. That issue was addressed a long time ago.
- ascorbic 11y agoYes, there are laws, they're completely ineffective. They need to end the fiction that subsidiaries of a multinational are in any way independent financially.
- icebraining 11y agoSaying they are not independent doesn't solve the issue of in which country they should pay their income taxes.
- ptaipale 11y agoYou see this claim, and at the same time you see the very same activists insist that there must be "country by country reporting" of independent financial country organisations. Well, that pretty much exists already. But the claim that the laws are "completely ineffective" is unsubstantianted.
- ascorbic 11y agoThe fact that the kind of artificial arrangements exist proves that the laws are meaningless.
- ptaipale 11y agoWhat artificial arrangements? OECD countries in general and CJEC countries in particular have signed agreements that enforce tax rules such that the tax collecting authorities as a rule bypass any artificial arrangements. To be lawful, national tax regulations must be proportionate and specifically aimed at preventing "purely artificial arrangements".
- morgante 11y agoYes, it is "tax avoidance." Tax avoidance is 100% legal. Tax evasion is what's illegal and they're not doing that here. Everything they're doing is by the book—there aren't any secrets to be found.
- justincormack 11y agoI don't know why you are convinced it is legal. Google and Apple are currently making settlements with pretty much every government in Europe. Apple may well have to pay Ireland several billion dollars in taxes because the deal they did is likely to be ruled illegal.
- sokoloff 11y agoThe difference is that tax avoidance is defined as legal and tax evasion defined as illegal (at least in the US). If it's a legal activity aimed at minimizing taxes, it's avoidance. Likewise, if it's avoidance, it's legal, and if it's not legal, it's not avoidance. From the IRS manual, section 25.1.1.2.4 .1 & .2 [0] [1] Avoidance of tax is not a criminal offense. Taxpayers have the right to reduce, avoid, or minimize their taxes by legitimate means. One who avoids tax does not conceal or misrepresent, but shapes and preplans events to reduce or eliminate tax liability within the parameters of the law. Evasion involves some affirmative act to evade or defeat a tax, or payment of tax. Examples of affirmative acts are deceit, subterfuge, camouflage, concealment, attempts to color or obscure events, or make things seem other than they are. If I move to Florida or Texas to escape paying state income tax on my earnings, that's avoidance. If I earned the money in Massachusetts and simply decide to not declare and pay tax on it, that's evasion. What's happening to some of the multi-nationals is that their attempts at structuring their affairs are being judged on the wrong side of the line. While it may not be being called evasion legally in all cases, it's exceeded the bounds of avoidance, resulting in settlements. [0] - https://www.irs.gov/irm/part25/irm_25-001-001.html#d0e299 https://www.irs.gov/irm/part25/irm_25-001-001.html#d0e299 (light emphasis mine) [1] - That section numbering scheme itself gives a clue as to how complex the tax code is.
- justincormack 11y ago
- ptaipale 11y ago> The allocation of the income between the different subsidiaries is almost completely arbitrary Not quite. Each country has provisions in their tax code to assess the transfer pricing, and they tend to defend their tax intake quite aggressively. So much so, that e.g. in EU, the EU courts are often needed to reign in the tax collectors. This is then headlined as "EU allows tax loopholes for Google" or whatever. As a random example of pointing out how the transfer pricing regimes work in different countries, see https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/global/Documents/Tax/dttl-tax-transfer-pricing-country-guide-2015.pdf https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/global/Docume... This of course only scratches the surface. A common keyword for the policies is "arm's length principle", which means that allocation of income is not determined by the company, but nor is it determined by the tax revenue activists which infuriates them. It is determined by a legal process - undoubtedly not always perfect, but certainly not arbitrarily decided by companies. Too many people get their education about this from Internet memes.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> A common keyword for the policies is "arm's length principle", which means that allocation of income is not determined by the company, but nor is it determined by the tax revenue activists which infuriates them. It is determined by a legal process - undoubtedly not always perfect, but certainly not arbitrarily decided by companies. It effectively is decided by companies though. Because arms length transactions have enough play in them. It isn't a matter of saying "we license you all our intellectual property for $1 and then you license it to them over there for $1 Billion" because they don't actually need that. They only need the difference to wipe out their profits in jurisdictions with high taxes. And they get to decide what transactions to engage in. Here's a made up example which is probably about right. If you have capital and an idea you can pay a consultancy to write code implementing it, and the consultancy is going to pay out in salaries nearly as much as you pay them. Their profit margin is very small. On the other hand, once you have the copyright to some useful software and can then sell it to a billion people, the revenue is pretty much pure profit. If you then license that software through a reseller, the vast majority of the profit goes to the copyright owner, not the reseller. That's what everything legitimately looks like with arms length transactions. Because the person paying the consultancy and then licensing the software is the one risking their capital not knowing whether the enterprise will be a success, so they're the one who makes all the money. So then they put the consultancy in the US, the copyright owner in Ireland and the resellers in the rest of the EU. The company in Ireland then makes all the money, just like arms length transactions say they should. It's tax arbitrage. They say you have to pay a tax on profit, but capital generates profit. Money makes money. So the company puts their capital into a place with low taxes and then can legitimately say "we used that capital to make all this money." It's literally an attempt to tax something that can be instantaneously moved anywhere in the world and then being shocked and amazed that as soon as the rate is lower somewhere else, that's where the money goes.