4 ms·
It's not the same thing at all, some things are exempt from tax this is a "smart" tax policy that is instituted to ensure that people save money, in the US you
by dogma1138 11y ago
It's not the same thing at all, some things are exempt from tax this is a "smart" tax policy that is instituted to ensure that people save money, in the US you have an IRA in the UK it's called an ISA, most countries also give you tax credit for participating in a pension scheme.
If you want a good analogy on a "personal" level (even tho there isn't really one) is that if you would transfer all your property to an offshore trust and they pay yourself rent deducting the rental costs from your overall taxes under various schemes.
If a normal individual would play the same game they would be singled out for tax evasion, and while if you are wealthy enough you can hide behind off shore trusts and shell corporations you money is often tied down considerably more than the money of a multi-billion dollar corporation.
Google can't really move that money easily either if they want to move it into the US they'll have to pay taxes eventually but as long as they keep it offshore they can use that money for credit as well as actually pay out any debts they might have to presumably other multi-billion dollar corporations without having to pay taxes on it.
But what usually they do is either wait for a "bad" year or when they have enough carry over deductions to move their money back in without paying any taxes due to deductible or horde it until they'll get a good deal and only have to pay a fraction of the tax that they would've normally pay (and every couple of years you read that corp X has came to agreement with country Y to pay couple of billions in tax, what you often do not read is that amount is usually less than a quarter of what was actually due).
Now don't get me wrong Google isn't doing anything illegal, and unfortunately as a public company they are pretty much forced to do it because otherwise they open the selves to their investors because if a company "intentionally" waste a shitload of money it will have to answer to their investors and the board can kiss their positions and bonuses good bye.
The problem is that international taxation is complicated there isn't a single good international tax treaty and when you involve multiple jurisdictions you complicate things even further because even if the US will have a treaty to collect taxes from say an Irish subsidiary when it does not generate any taxable income in Ireland because it's in account debt to another subsidiary in Bermuda there's nothing you can do.
One of the "good" sides of the TTTP is that it actually gives (at least the US) quite substantial tax collecting provisions as well as limits the taxes that can be set on US goods, while this might help the US many of the other countries might get screwed over this because it doesn't necessarily works both ways.
- refurb 11y agoIt's not the same thing at all, some things are exempt from tax this is a "smart" tax policy that is instituted to ensure that people save money Read the bottom part of my message again. Yes, the Roth IRA is meant as a savings vehicle, but not for high income earners (>$137K/yr). However, the law is setup so that you can get around it by just putting your money into a regular IRA and converting it to a Roth. The gov't never intended for people to do that (since it gets around the income limit). However, it's completely legal.
- morgante 11y agoYou missed the part where the Roth backdoor is very deliberately subverting the intent of the law. Congress deliberately put an income cap on who can contribute to Roth IRAs. It's obviously there in the law and the intent is clear. However, thanks to the conversion backdoor, high income earners can still contribute to Roth IRAs—against the intent of the law. To me, this is exactly as moral as what corporations do to avoid taxes.
- sokoloff 11y agoI'm not convinced it's either bad for the government nor against the intent of the drafters. (It would be easy to claim "Oh, we never intended this to be a handout to rich fat cats; see, it's right here in the law. Ooops, we didn't think of this super-obvious workaround, but hey, we tried...") When you do a Roth conversion, that income has already been taxed once (either at the moment of conversion for a previously pre-tax account, or by virtue of funding it with already-taxed money). On all the money that was previously pre-tax (traditional IRA for example), the government gets its tax income now at the moment of Roth conversion instead of much later. If the government or the individual would make the same investments, get the same return, and the tax rates would be the same, the government would get the same money either way. The problem is the government is running deficits and so isn't investing the money like a wealthy individual would and so isn't getting the same long-run tax income from it. This part is a spending problem, not a tax policy problem, IMO. The only reason I'm not doing Roth conversions is that I don't trust our government to stay solvent enough long enough to keep the deal that Roth withdrawals will be tax-free later. Instead, I keep my post-tax money in traditional brokerage accounts or other non-tax-advantaged vehicles where I'm more sure that the gains will only be taxed one more time, but where I keep the flexibility to invest and use the money.