3 ms·
20 developers has lower productivity for a lot more reasons than individual incentives. This has been widely recognized since The Mythical Man-Month. Concrete
by btilly 17y ago
20 developers has lower productivity for a lot more reasons than individual incentives. This has been widely recognized since The Mythical Man-Month.
Concrete data point for you that I ran across in Software Estimation by Steve McConnell. The average team of 5-8 programmers can get a medium sized project done in the same calendar time as a team of 20 programmers. As teams grow beyond 20 programmers, total throughput improves. This is from a study with project side measured in lines of code. There is every reason to believe that the larger team has more reinvention within their project, and therefore their project of equivalent size has less functionality.
The fundamental reason has to do with lines of communication. As you add a person to a team, the number of lines of communication you add is the size of the team. At some point people take up more energy from others than they contribute useful work themselves. There are a myriad of organizational techniques which try to mitigate this problem, but all suffer from the defect that they force people to use less productive forms of communication (for instance writing documents that can be read by many others), and therefore lower individual productivity.
Therefore if you've got 20 developers you should seriously consider going back to a small team, find a way to partition them into groups with minimal interactions, or scale your organization up until you have a lot more developers than that. The first two try to solve organizational problems that lead to low throughput, the last accepts the issues but lets you tackle problems that the small team couldn't.
Another random suggestion. If you're interested in productivity, pick up a copy of Peopleware and Rapid Development, read them, and pick a set of best practices to try.
- bokonist 17y agoWe already have teams of 3-4 developers, working on separate projects with minimal interactions. If we didn't do that we would be thrashing. We're aware of the Peopleware/Mythical Man Month issue. But still, I think we could do better. Working based on hitting external goals adds invaluable focus to a team.